Trustee duties and powers
The core duties
A trustee’s first duty is to follow the trust’s terms. This is the standard for every other duty. The trustee must know the terms, and any departure is a breach, even if well-meaning. If the terms are unclear, the trustee may ask the court for directions, which protects them.
Trustees must act personally and jointly. They must use their own judgment. Delegation was once banned, but trustee legislation now allows it within limits, with a duty to choose and supervise delegates carefully. Co-trustees must generally act unanimously, unless the trust says otherwise, and a trustee cannot avoid responsibility by leaving decisions to a co-trustee.
Trustees must exercise care and skill. The general standard is that of an ordinary prudent businessperson managing someone else’s affairs. Paid or professional trustees are held to a higher standard.
When investing, trustees must meet the prudent person standard, replacing older lists of approved investments. They must consider things like the trust’s purpose, diversification, risk of loss, liquidity, tax, and costs. Most jurisdictions also require periodic review of investments, allow reliance on professional advice, and let courts offset a gain on one investment against a loss on another when deciding liability.
Trustees must act impartially between beneficiaries, including those entitled to income and those entitled to capital. This affects how they invest.
Trustees must keep proper accounts and give them to beneficiaries on request. Whether they must explain their reasons for a discretionary decision is different, and is covered in the beneficiaries’ rights article.
Finally, trustees must collect and preserve trust property. They must not profit from the trust or allow conflicts of interest — this is the fiduciary duty.
Powers
Powers are things a trustee may do. This is different from duties, which a trustee must do.
Powers come from two places: the trust instrument itself, and trustee legislation. The legislation gives default powers, such as sale, leasing, insurance, maintenance and advancement, plus a power to compromise claims.
A trustee must still exercise any power properly. The power must be used in good faith, for the purpose it was given, and with real and genuine consideration.
If a trustee exercises a power outside these limits, it may be set aside as a fraud on the power. This term does not require dishonesty; it simply means the power was used improperly.
Breach of trust
A trustee who breaches their duty must restore the trust fund or pay equitable compensation. This liability is personal, meaning it comes from the trustee’s own assets. The test, confirmed in Youyang Pty Ltd v Minter Ellison Morris Fletcher, asks what the fund would have held if the duty had been performed, valued at judgment.
If the breach produced a profit, the trustee must account for it. A constructive trust (where the court treats property as held for the beneficiary) may also attach to that property.
Trustees are liable only for their own breaches, not automatically for a co-trustee’s. But staying passive about a known breach is itself a breach. Co-trustees are generally each liable for the whole loss, with rights to claim contribution from one another.
Several defences apply. A fully informed, capable adult beneficiary who consents or acquiesces cannot later sue. Exculpation clauses (clauses excusing trustees from liability) are common and work to a point, but are read strictly against the trustee; they never excuse dishonesty, and their effect on gross negligence is limited and unsettled.
Courts may also grant statutory relief, excusing a trustee wholly or partly if they acted honestly and reasonably and ought fairly to be excused. Both elements are required.
Limitation periods usually apply, but not to fraudulent breaches or to trust property still held by the trustee.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.