Tracing

Common law and equitable tracing

Common law tracing follows an asset through clean substitutions. It fails once funds are mixed with other money, because the asset can no longer be identified.

Equity’s tracing rules matter because they can follow assets through mixtures. Courts have usually required a fiduciary relationship first, meaning a relationship of trust and confidence. Many criticise this requirement as doing no real work, and courts have accepted weak evidence to find one. Treat this requirement as something to address, not assume is correct.

Equity can also trace assets into the hands of third parties. This is subject to defences covered elsewhere.

Mixed funds

When a trustee mixes their own money with trust money, the law treats this against the trustee. Courts presume the trustee spent their own money first. This presumption protects the trust fund.

If the mixed fund buys an asset that rises in value, Foskett v McKeown lets the beneficiary choose. They can claim a proportionate share, gaining the increase in value. Or they can claim an equitable charge, a security interest for the amount taken. A charge is better if the asset has fallen in value. The beneficiary makes this choice.

A claim against a mixed account cannot exceed its lowest intermediate balance. This is the lowest point the account reached between the wrongdoing and the claim. Money paid in later from elsewhere does not top up the trust fund, unless the trustee meant it to.

When two innocent people’s funds are mixed, neither presumption applies, since neither is a wrongdoer. For active current accounts, courts have traditionally used first-in-first-out. But this rule is seen as arbitrary. Australian courts will depart from it when it is unjust or impractical, preferring rateable sharing based on contributions, or a rolling proportionate method.

If trust money is simply spent, on a holiday, a meal, or an unsecured debt, there is no traceable substitute. The tracing claim ends there. But paying off a secured debt may let the claimant be subrogated to that security, meaning they step into the secured creditor’s shoes.

Backwards tracing treats an asset bought before the misappropriation as the trust’s substitute. This is unsettled law. Some jurisdictions accept it where the transactions formed one coordinated scheme. Treat it as an open argument, not a settled rule.

Claiming, and the defences

After tracing succeeds, the claimant picks a proprietary claim or a personal claim. Proprietary claims are usually better. They win priority if the defendant is insolvent, and they capture any increase in value.

Some defences can defeat these claims. Being a bona fide purchaser of the legal estate for value without notice is a complete defence to a proprietary claim. This means the court must look closely at who each recipient actually is.

Change of position is a defence to personal liability. It protects an innocent recipient who has irreversibly changed their position relying on the money. Australian law recognises this defence, but it will not help a wrongdoer.

An innocent volunteer is someone who received property for free, acting innocently. They are not personally liable for property they no longer have, though the property itself can still be traced.

Delay and acquiescence can also operate as a defence.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.