The three certainties
Certainty of intention
Certainty of intention comes from the case Knight v Knight. It asks whether the person actually meant to create a trust, an enforceable duty to hold property for someone else.
Courts look at the substance of the words and conduct, not just the labels used. No particular wording is needed, and using the word “trust” is neither essential nor automatically enough.
Precatory words, like hope, wish, desire, confidence, or request, generally do not create a trust. But depending on context, they sometimes can.
In commercial settings, context matters too. Putting money in a separate account for a specific purpose may show a trust was intended, while a general promise to use money a certain way usually just creates a debt.
A trust must also be clearly distinguished from other arrangements, such as a gift, a debt, a charge, or an agency relationship.
If no trust was actually intended, the arrangement fails as a trust. The recipient then either keeps the property for themselves, or the arrangement takes effect as whatever it really is, usually a gift or a debt.
Certainty of subject matter
Certainty of subject matter has two parts, and both must be met.
First, the trust property must be clearly identified. Vague descriptions, like “the bulk of my estate,” are not enough. Tangible property that is not separated out is usually not certain enough either — you cannot declare a trust over fifty cases of wine from a larger stock, because no one can tell which fifty are meant.
Intangible property, like shares, is treated more leniently. Because one share in a class is identical to another, a trust over a stated number of shares in a single holding can still be valid. This different treatment of tangible and intangible property is criticised, but remains the accepted approach.
Second, the beneficial interests must be identified. The trust must make clear what each beneficiary is entitled to. This can be done through a formula or a mechanism for working it out later, and a discretionary trust satisfies this by letting the trustee decide the allocation.
If the trust property itself is uncertain, there is no trust at all. If the property is certain but the beneficial interests are not, the trustee instead holds the property on a resulting trust for the settlor — meaning it goes back to them.
Certainty of objects
Certainty of objects means knowing who the beneficiaries are. The test used depends on what kind of disposition it is.
For a fixed trust, the trustee must split the property into set shares. This needs the complete list test: every beneficiary must be identifiable, or shares cannot be calculated.
For a discretionary trust, the trustee must distribute but chooses among a class. This needs criterion certainty: the court asks if any given person is or is not in the class. No complete list is required.
For a mere power of appointment, the donee may appoint but does not have to. The same is-or-is-not test applies, but the court supervises less closely.
Two distinctions matter in harder cases. Conceptual uncertainty means the class description itself is unclear, like “my good friends.” This is always fatal to the trust.
Evidential uncertainty is different: the description is clear, but proving who fits it is hard. This is not fatal. The trustee simply distributes to those who can prove their claim.
A discretionary trust can also fail for administrative unworkability, where the class is so wide the trustee cannot sensibly exercise discretion. It can fail too for capriciousness, where the class has no rational link to any discernible intention.
If certainty of objects fails, the trust property is held on resulting trust, returning to the settlor or their estate.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.