Resulting trusts

Automatic resulting trusts

An automatic resulting trust arises when a beneficial interest is never properly given away. It goes back to the settlor, or their estate if they have died.

This happens in three situations. First, when an express trust fails, because its objects or beneficial interests are uncertain, there is no beneficiary, or it is illegal. Second, when the trust leaves a surplus after its stated purposes are met. Third, when a condition the trust depended on is not satisfied.

No presumption needs rebutting here. The interest has nowhere else to go, so the trustee simply holds it for the settlor.

Harder cases arise when many people contribute to a fund for a purpose that later fails, such as a disaster appeal or a dissolved association. Courts have used different approaches: a resulting trust for the contributors, distribution following the contract between members, or bona vacantia (property with no owner, which passes to the state). Which approach applies depends on how the original contribution was characterised.

Presumed resulting trusts

Equity assumes people do not mean to give property away for nothing. This creates a presumed resulting trust in two situations.

First, a voluntary transfer: A gives property to B, and B pays nothing for it. Equity presumes B holds the property on trust for A. For land, some jurisdictions have statutes changing this, so check local law.

Second, a purchase in another’s name: A pays for property, but it is put in B’s name, or in both names. B is presumed to hold it on trust for A, matching A’s share of the purchase price. This comes from Calverley v Green (1984) 155 CLR 242.

The purchase price resulting trust matters most in practice. It is measured only by contributions to the purchase price when the property was bought. Later mortgage payments, improvements, or household expenses do not count here. Those instead belong to the constructive trust.

The presumption of advancement

Sometimes the presumption of resulting trust flips. This happens where the provider would normally be expected to give the recipient a gift.

In that case, a counter-presumption applies: the presumption of advancement. It assumes a gift was intended, not a trust.

Australian law recognises this in certain relationships, like father to child, and husband to wife.

But courts today question whether this presumption still makes sense. It traditionally never applied the other way — wife to husband, or mother to child.

Courts have criticised this asymmetry but have not abolished the presumption. Treat it as weak and easily rebutted by evidence, not as a firm rule.

Rebuttal

These presumptions are presumptions of fact. This means real evidence of what someone actually intended can override them.

They only matter when there is no clear evidence, or the evidence is evenly balanced. This is why they usually come up in family disputes, long after the transaction happened.

Courts prefer evidence of intention from the time of the transaction. Statements made later, especially self-serving ones, carry little weight.

Sometimes the transferor’s purpose was illegal, such as hiding assets from creditors, a spouse, or tax authorities. Whether this blocks evidence of intention has shifted over time.

The modern approach avoids automatically excluding such evidence. Instead, courts ask whether allowing the claim would conflict with the purpose of the law that was broken.

The relationship with constructive trusts

Resulting trusts and constructive trusts both arise by operation of law. Courts and lawyers often run them together, but they ask different questions.

A resulting trust asks who paid for the property, looked at when it was bought. A constructive trust asks what conscience requires, and can look at contributions and conduct throughout the relationship.

If a purchase money resulting trust does not reflect what the parties did later, use a constructive trust instead.

The presumptions used in resulting trust cases are a fallback, not a starting point. In Bosanac v Commissioner of Taxation (2022), the court held that the presumption cannot override the actual intention of the person who paid, where that intention is shown by the overall evidence.

So start with the evidence of intention. Only use the presumption if that evidence does not give an answer.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.