Express trusts

Creating a trust

There are two ways to create a trust, and each becomes complete at a different point.

The first is declaration. The owner simply declares themselves trustee of their own property. No transfer is needed, but the intention must be shown clearly. Just using the word “trust” does not automatically create one.

Once a trust is validly declared, it stands. In Byrnes v Kendle (2011) 243 CLR 253, the trustee later acted inconsistently with the trust. The court held this later conduct did not prove the trust was never really intended.

The second way is transfer. Here the settlor gives property to a trustee, to be held on stated trusts. This trust is only complete once the property is actually vested in the trustee.

Vesting depends on the type of property. Torrens land and shares require registration, chattels require delivery, and choses in action require assignment.

Constitution, and the volunteer

If a settlor means to transfer property to a trustee but never finishes the transfer, the trust is incompletely constituted. Equity will not assist a volunteer, meaning someone who gave nothing for the gift. So a beneficiary who gave no consideration cannot force the transfer to be completed.

There are exceptions. If the settlor has done everything necessary on their part, leaving only a third party’s act like registration, the trust may still be valid. It may also stand if the intended trustee already holds the legal title in another role, such as executor.

A covenant to settle, a promise to create a trust, can still be enforced if given for value, or by people covered by marriage consideration. Unconscionable resiling, unfairly going back on the arrangement, may also found an estoppel, a bar preventing that unfairness.

Finally, courts will not rescue an imperfect gift by treating it instead as a self-declaration of trust. These reflect different intentions, and one cannot be substituted for the other.

Formalities

Statute affects trusts in three ways, and details vary between jurisdictions.

For land, a declaration of trust must be shown in signed writing. This is only an evidentiary rule: an oral declaration is not void, just unenforceable until proven in writing. Courts will not let the statute be used to commit fraud.

For existing equitable interests, any disposition must be in writing, signed by the person giving it up or their agent.

For testamentary trusts (trusts starting on death), the normal will formalities must be met. Secret and half-secret trusts are allowed as exceptions, enforced because the person’s conscience is bound by what they agreed to do.

Resulting, implied and constructive trusts are not covered by these writing requirements at all.

The beneficiary principle

A trust needs a beneficiary the court can enforce it for. This is called the beneficiary principle.

A private trust set up only for a purpose, not a person, usually fails. There is no beneficiary to ask the court to enforce it.

There is a small, old exception. Courts tolerate trusts for things like maintaining particular animals or graves, though they do not encourage them.

Charitable trusts are the major exception to the beneficiary principle. They can exist purely for a purpose, without needing certain beneficiaries, and can last forever. The Attorney-General enforces them instead of a beneficiary.

To count as charitable, the purpose must fit a recognised head of charity. It must also benefit the public. Commonwealth charities legislation now adds extra rules to these heads, for regulatory purposes.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by identifying the property, the intended trustee, and the intended beneficiaries.

Then ask how the trust was made. Was it by declaration or by transfer? Check whether it is constituted, meaning properly set up.

Next, work through the three certainties.

Check the formalities too. These depend on the type of property and how the trust was created.

Finally, if the trust fails, say what happens to the property. Usually it returns to the settlor or their estate under a resulting trust.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.