Constructive trusts

Institutional or remedial

Quick Read: Institutional or remedial

There are two kinds of constructive trust, and the key question is when each arises.

An institutional constructive trust arises automatically when certain events happen. The court simply declares it exists. Property rights under it, including those of third parties and creditors, date back to that earlier time.

A remedial constructive trust is different. The court imposes it as a remedy, and the court decides when it starts and what form it takes.

Australia recognises both types. This differs from England, which rejects the remedial constructive trust, and from Canada, which uses it widely.

Australia’s approach sits in between. A remedial constructive trust is available, but only as a last resort. Courts will only impose it if other remedies, like equitable compensation or an account (personal money remedies), are not enough.

Courts also consider the impact on third parties and unsecured creditors. To protect them, a court may rule the trust only takes effect from the date of judgment, rather than earlier.

Domestic property disputes

Domestic property disputes often use the joint endeavour principle. This comes from Muschinski v Dodds. It asks what each party contributed to the relationship, including money, work, and care.

The court then asks what would be unconscionable, meaning unfair in a way equity won’t allow, for one party to keep after the relationship ends. A resulting trust based on who paid the purchase price is often the starting point. But it is rarely the final answer.

Two qualifications apply. First, most couples will instead use family law property rules, which give courts wider discretion. Equitable claims still matter when those rules don’t apply, when a third party has an interest, or on insolvency or death.

Second, this constructive trust creates a proprietary interest, meaning a right in the property itself. This affects creditors, which is one reason courts apply the doctrine cautiously.

Third party liability

Someone who is not a trustee can still be personally liable in equity. This happens in two situations.

The first is knowing receipt. This means receiving trust property for your own benefit, while knowing it was a breach of trust.

The second is knowing assistance. This means helping a trustee or fiduciary carry out a dishonest and fraudulent design, while knowing about it.

Australian law still requires this dishonest and fraudulent design for knowing assistance. It has not adopted a broader test based on unconscionability, unlike other places.

Courts assess “knowledge” on a sliding scale. This ranges from actual knowledge down to knowledge of facts that would make an honest, reasonable person ask questions. For knowing receipt specifically, exactly how much knowledge is needed is not yet fully settled.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.