Beneficiary rights

The nature of the interest

In a fixed trust, the beneficiary owns a proprietary equitable interest in the trust property. This interest can be assigned, charged, or left in a will. It is also protected if the trustee becomes insolvent, since the trust property is not available to the trustee’s creditors.

In a discretionary trust, an object has no proprietary interest in any asset until the trustee exercises discretion in their favour. Instead, they have a right to be considered, a right to proper administration of the trust, and a right to stop misuse of the fund.

Because of this, a discretionary interest is generally not treated as property that the object’s own creditors can claim, or that forms part of their bankrupt estate. This is one reason discretionary trusts are commonly used.

In a unit trust, the trust instrument governs unitholders’ rights. These rights are usually closer to those of a beneficiary under a fixed trust.

Rights to information

A beneficiary can inspect the trust instrument (the document setting up the trust). They can also make the trustee account for how the fund has been managed.

This right comes from the trustee’s duty to account, not from “discovery” (a court process for getting documents in a lawsuit). So a beneficiary does not need to start court proceedings to use it.

Reasons for discretionary decisions are treated differently. A trustee usually does not have to explain why they made a discretionary choice.

If no reasons are given, courts will not force disclosure just because a beneficiary is unhappy. But if the trustee does give reasons, those reasons can be examined.

Today, courts treat this as part of their inherent supervisory jurisdiction (their built-in power to oversee trustees). They weigh the interests of all beneficiaries, protect others’ confidentiality, and consider how strong the beneficiary’s interest is.

Because of this, someone who is only one of many possible beneficiaries in a wide discretionary class may get less information than a beneficiary with a fixed, certain interest.

Ending the trust

If all beneficiaries are adults with full capacity, and together they own the whole beneficial interest, they can act unanimously. This is the rule in Saunders v Vautier. They can tell the trustee to hand over the property and end the trust, even if the settlor wanted them to wait longer.

Australia still applies this rule. The United States mostly dropped it, preferring to follow the settlor’s main purpose instead. So American writing on this topic does not reliably apply in Australia.

The rule only lets beneficiaries end the trust entirely. It does not let them control how the trustee uses discretion while the trust continues.

Enforcing the trust

A beneficiary’s main right is against the trustee. The beneficiary can ask the trustee to restore the trust fund, pay equitable compensation, or properly administer the trust.

A beneficiary can usually only sue a third party if the trustee cannot or will not act. This is because the trustee holds legal title. The trustee is normally joined in such a claim.

There are three separate claims against third parties, and they should not be mixed up. First, following and tracing lets a beneficiary trace trust property into someone else’s hands. This proprietary claim fails if a bona fide purchaser bought the legal estate for value without notice.

Second, knowing receipt is a personal claim. It applies against a stranger who receives trust property for their own benefit, knowing of the breach of trust.

Third, knowing assistance is a personal claim against a stranger who knowingly helps a trustee carry out a dishonest and fraudulent scheme. Australian law requires this dishonest and fraudulent design, unlike broader unconscionability-based tests used elsewhere. This difference is examinable.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.