Statutory modification of tort law

Harmonised in theme, not uniform in text

These statutes share a common template. People often call them harmonised, meaning they follow similar themes. But they are not uniform in their actual text.

They differ in wording. Thresholds and tests are phrased differently across states. Sometimes this difference changes the outcome of a case.

They also differ in structure. The same rule can appear in different provisions in each Act. A section number you learned for one state may be wrong in another.

Scope varies too. Some schemes cover any claim for harm, however it is framed. Others apply only to negligence, or only to personal injury.

Content differs as well. Some jurisdictions adopted provisions that others rejected. This is especially true for dangerous recreational activities, mental harm and exemplary damages.

Because of these differences, reasoning from one state’s provision to another is a serious error. Reading national textbooks and summaries can make this mistake easy to make.

What the statutes modify

Breach asks if harm was foreseeable and not insignificant, and whether precautions were reasonable. Courts weigh listed factors and must not judge with hindsight.

Causation has two limbs: factual causation and scope of liability. There is an exception for unusual cases, plus a special evidence rule about a plaintiff’s own statements in failure-to-warn claims.

For obvious and inherent risks, people are presumed to know obvious risks, so there is no duty to warn of them. There is also no liability if an inherent risk simply happens.

Some jurisdictions also remove liability for harm from an obvious risk of a dangerous recreational activity, but only where that rule was adopted.

The professional standard defence lets professionals rely on peer professional opinion. Courts can still reject that opinion if it is irrational, and this defence does not cover the duty to warn or inform patients.

For public authorities, their conduct is judged against their resources and overall responsibilities, not in isolation. Extra protection applies to policy decisions and special statutory powers.

Good samaritans and volunteers helping in good faith during emergencies are protected from personal liability, as are volunteers for community organisations.

Where a person was intoxicated or committing a crime, contributory negligence is presumed. In some jurisdictions, damages can be denied or limited if the injury occurred during a serious offence.

Damages provisions cap non-economic loss and weekly economic loss payments, require a minimum severity threshold, set gratuitous care minimums, restrict interest, and limit or abolish exemplary and aggravated damages for negligence-based personal injury.

Proportionate liability now applies to most economic loss and property damage claims, replacing solidary (joint) liability in most jurisdictions.

Finally, apology provisions state that making an apology is not itself an admission of legal liability.

Where the schemes do not apply

Before applying any civil liability Act, check what it excludes. Motor accident and workers’ compensation schemes have their own separate statutory regimes. Together they cover a large share of personal injury claims in Australia.

Dust diseases are excluded too, but only in jurisdictions that have dedicated schemes for them.

Intentional torts are also excluded from the damages rules in several jurisdictions. This includes acts intended to cause injury or death, and sexual assault.

Some jurisdictions exclude tobacco-related harm as well.

Claims under Commonwealth statutes are not affected by state civil liability Acts at all. So a claim for misleading conduct, or one under a Commonwealth safety law, escapes the state caps.

Because intentional torts often sit outside these caps, a plaintiff may recover more suing in trespass than in negligence, where the facts allow it. This is a genuine pleading consideration, not just a technicality.

The relationship with the common law

The statutes do not replace the common law. Courts still use common law rules for things the statutes leave untouched, like duty of care, standard of care, remoteness, and heads of damage.

Where a statute does deal with an issue, the statute controls. Courts treat it as ordinary legislation, not as a restatement of old case law.

Even if a provision copies a common law rule, courts still interpret its own wording. If a provision changes the common law, courts apply the new wording as written.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by working out which jurisdiction applies. You cannot safely say anything else until this is settled.

Next, check whether that jurisdiction’s civil liability scheme covers the claim. Some claims are excluded, or fall under a separate scheme instead.

Then state the statutory test using that jurisdiction’s own Act. Use the common law to fill any gaps the statute leaves, and to help interpret the statute’s wording.

If the facts do not make the jurisdiction clear, say so. Then explain which differences between jurisdictions would actually matter to the answer.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.