Negligence: remoteness and scope of liability
The test
Damage is too remote unless the kind of harm was reasonably foreseeable. This test comes from The Wagon Mound (No 1). “Remote” means too disconnected from the defendant’s conduct to count legally.
The exact manner the harm happened, and how serious it turned out to be, do not need to be foreseeable.
So the kind of harm matters most. Courts ask whether this general type of injury, like burning, was foreseeable, not the specific events leading to it.
An unusual chain of events can still lead to liability, as long as the kind of harm was foreseeable. Likewise, harm worse than expected is still recoverable if its kind was foreseeable.
The tricky part is deciding how broadly or narrowly to describe the “kind” of harm. Courts have no fixed rule for this. Characterisation should fit the facts honestly, and students should note how a different framing could change the result.
The eggshell skull rule
The eggshell skull rule means the defendant takes the plaintiff as they find them. If a plaintiff is unusually vulnerable, they still recover in full for the harm they actually suffer.
This fits with the foreseeability limit. The kind of harm must be foreseeable, but the extent of harm does not need to be foreseeable.
The rule also covers impecuniosity, meaning a lack of money. If a plaintiff’s loss is made worse because they cannot afford repairs or treatment, they can still recover.
Foreseeability doing three different jobs
Negligence has three stages. Each stage asks a different question, and each uses a different test.
Duty asks whether the parties had a relationship where care is owed. This test is undemanding. The risk just needs to be more than far-fetched or fanciful.
Breach asks whether a reasonable person would have taken precautions. This test is statutory. The harm must be foreseeable and not insignificant.
Remoteness asks whether this kind of harm falls within the scope of liability. Here the test is whether the kind of harm was reasonably foreseeable.
These are three separate questions, with three separate thresholds, assessed at different points. Saying “the harm was foreseeable” once does not answer all three. Using that single phrase to satisfy every stage skips two of them.
Scope of liability more broadly
Scope of liability is more than just remoteness. The statutes ask courts to decide if it is appropriate for liability to cover the harm that happened.
This involves looking at intervening acts, which are later events breaking the chain of causation. Courts also look at the purpose of the duty or rule that was breached.
The key question is whether the harm is the kind the duty was meant to prevent. If a duty only guards against a specific risk, other harms may fall outside it.
This means harm can be factually caused by the breach, yet still fall outside the scope of liability.
Successive events and vicissitudes
Sometimes a second, unrelated event would have caused the same injury anyway. When that happens, damages are adjusted to reflect this.
Courts also allow for the general vicissitudes of life. This means life’s ordinary ups and downs are factored into a discount on damages for future loss.
Both ideas rest on the same comparison. They ask what position the plaintiff would be in if the tort had never happened, compared to their actual position now. This comparison is also how damages are measured.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.