Negligence: causation
Factual causation: the but-for test
The but-for test asks: would the harm have happened without the defendant’s negligence? If it would have happened anyway, factual causation fails, however careless the defendant was.
March v E & MH Stramare Pty Ltd (1991) established that the but-for test is a useful filter, not the complete answer. Common sense and a value judgment about responsibility also matter. The test fails in two situations: multiple sufficient causes, where two separate negligent acts would each cause the whole harm, and evidentiary gaps in disease cases where the injury’s mechanism cannot be traced.
Adeels Palace Pty Ltd v Moubarak (2009) applied the but-for test under New South Wales statute. Two men were shot during a brawl at a licensed venue and sued the operator for failing to provide security. The High Court held that factual causation under s 5D(1)(a) of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) uses the but-for test, and the plaintiffs had not proved it. They did not show it was more probable than not that security would have prevented the shootings.
Showing a possibility that things might have gone differently was not enough. The Court also said that the injury being the kind the duty aimed to prevent could matter for scope of liability, but it did not prove factual causation. The Court did not decide whether the operator had breached its duty.
Young v Chief Executive Officer (Housing) [2023] cast doubt on one phrase from March. Gordon and Edelman JJ said that describing causation using “common sense” should now be avoided. This was only two of five judges, and the case concerned statutory compensation for a tenant’s distress, not negligence. Their footnotes did, however, cite similar criticism from five earlier decisions of the Court.
Loss of a chance
The High Court says losing a chance of a better medical outcome is not compensable in negligence. If a plaintiff cannot prove, on the balance of probabilities, that negligence caused the physical injury, they get nothing for the lost chance. There is no partial recovery for a lower-percentage chance.
This is different from cases where the lost chance is a commercial opportunity with its own value. That kind of claim usually arises in contract or professional negligence, over a lost transaction or claim.
The key distinction: a lost chance of avoiding physical injury is not compensable. A lost chance that was itself the valuable thing can be.
Intervening acts
A later act can sometimes break the chain of responsibility for harm. This is an intervening act. The question is about scope of liability, not factual causation.
The original negligence remains a necessary cause either way. The real issue is whether liability should still extend that far.
A deliberate wrongful act by a third party is more likely to break the chain. A foreseeable careless response is less likely to.
Medical treatment for an injury the defendant caused usually won’t break the chain. The exception is if the treatment is grossly substandard.
The plaintiff’s own carelessness is normally treated as contributory negligence, not as a break in the chain.
Failure to warn
When the defendant failed to warn of a risk, factual causation looks at what this particular plaintiff would have done if warned. This is a subjective test, based on all the evidence.
In New South Wales, Queensland and Tasmania, a statutory rule applies. It says the plaintiff’s own statement, made after the harm, about what they would have done is inadmissible. The exception is where that statement goes against their own interest.
Victoria’s equivalent provision (Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic) s 51(3)) does not include this rule. Students should check the position in other jurisdictions separately.
The rule exists because such after-the-event statements are always coloured by hindsight. The plaintiff already knows the outcome when making them.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by keeping the two limbs of causation separate.
Apply the but-for test carefully. Ask what would have happened if the precaution had been taken.
If but-for fails, check whether this is a recognised exception. Explain why responsibility should still be imposed.
For failure to warn, ask the subjective question: what would this particular person have done? Note any statutory evidentiary rule that applies.
Under scope of liability, consider intervening acts, the purpose of the duty breached, and whether the harm is the kind the duty aimed to prevent.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.