Negligence: breach and the standard of care

The standard

The standard of care is objective. This means the court asks what a reasonable person would do, not what the defendant actually intended or tried to do.

Good intentions, inexperience and best efforts do not matter. For example, a learner driver must still meet the standard of a competent driver.

Two exceptions apply. A child is judged against a reasonable child of similar age. A person claiming a special skill is judged against a person who has that skill.

The statutory test

Quick Read: The statutory test

The civil liability statutes set a common test for breach. A person is not negligent for failing to take precautions unless three things are true: the risk was foreseeable, the risk was not insignificant, and a reasonable person would have taken those precautions.

“Not insignificant” sets a higher bar than the common law’s old test of “not far-fetched or fanciful”. This is why foreseeability at breach is a different enquiry from foreseeability at duty.

The statute also focuses on precautions. A plaintiff must say what the defendant should have done. Without this, breach is not established, no matter how serious the injury was.

The calculus of negligence

This framework comes from Wyong Shire Council v Shirt. Courts later wrote it into the civil liability statutes. It helps decide what a reasonable person would do about a risk.

Courts weigh four things: how probable the harm was, how serious it could be, how hard it would be to take precautions, and the social usefulness of the risky activity.

Always check the statute in your jurisdiction first, since wording differs between them. In Adeels Palace v Moubarak, the Court looked at s 5B of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW). It warned that the heading “Duty of care” above s 5B is misleading, since these are breach rules, not duty rules.

Section 5B(1) adds a threshold: the risk must be “not insignificant” before a failure to take precautions can be negligence. The case does not say whether this matches the Shirt test, so do not rely on it for that comparison.

The statutes list these factors but say the list is not complete. Two rules matter when applying them.

First, reason forward, not backward. Ask what a reasonable person would do before the injury, not what seems obvious afterward. The statutes warn against this hindsight bias.

Second, weigh the burden of the precaution, not the burden of the accident. A cheap precaution against a small chance of serious harm is usually required. An expensive precaution against a remote, minor risk usually is not.

Finally, following common industry practice is evidence of reasonable care, but not proof of it. An entire industry can still be found negligent.

Professionals

Professionals are judged against the standard of an ordinarily skilled member of their profession. Most jurisdictions also give professionals a statutory defence: peer professional opinion. This means a professional does not breach their duty if they acted in a way widely accepted by peers as competent practice.

But courts can reject that peer opinion if they think it is irrational.

This defence has an important limit. It does not cover the duty to warn of, or give information about, risks. Courts, not professional practice, decide if a patient or client got adequate information. This was the rule in Australia even before the statutes, and the statutes kept it that way.

Students often wrongly apply the peer opinion defence to information duties. Remember: the standard for treatment and the standard for giving information are different, and mixing them up is a common mistake.

Obvious and inherent risks

Quick Read: Obvious and inherent risks

An obvious risk is one a reasonable person in the plaintiff’s position would have seen coming. Statutes generally say there is no duty to warn someone about this kind of risk. But exceptions apply, like when the plaintiff asked for advice, or when a professional risk of death or injury comes from treatment.

An inherent risk is one that can’t be avoided even with reasonable care. The statutes say no one is liable if this type of risk actually happens.

These rules differ between states and territories. They also connect to other defences, like obvious risk and dangerous recreational activity.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.