Security for costs

Where the power comes from

Two legal sources work together here.

Each jurisdiction’s rules of court give courts a general discretion to order security for costs. These rules list situations where it may apply, such as a plaintiff living outside the jurisdiction, or one suing for someone else’s benefit.

For corporate plaintiffs, s 1335 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) gives a separate statutory power. If credible evidence shows the company won’t be able to pay the defendant’s costs if it loses, the court may order security and pause the case until it’s paid.

Courts also have an inherent jurisdiction to order security. This is a built-in power courts always hold, but it’s rarely needed given the other options.

The threshold, and then the discretion

There are two separate steps here, and mixing them up is a common mistake.

First, you ask whether the threshold is met. This means checking if the plaintiff is a corporation unable to pay, or fits another set category. Meeting the threshold does not force an order; it only opens up the court’s discretion.

Second, you ask whether the court should actually use that discretion. Courts weigh several factors together, rather than just counting them.

They look at the strength of the claim, without holding a mini-trial. A strong claim weighs against ordering security; a weak one favours it.

They ask whether the defendant’s own conduct caused the plaintiff’s poverty. If so, ordering security would unfairly add to that harm.

They consider whether an order would stifle a genuine claim — often the key factor. The plaintiff must show security would stop the case, and that people behind it (directors, shareholders, funders) also cannot or will not pay.

Delay matters too: a defendant who waits until trial faces a harder case, since costs are already spent.

A litigation funder’s presence strongly supports ordering security, especially if the plaintiff is really suing for someone else’s benefit.

Finally, courts weigh any public interest in resolving the case, where it raises a matter of general importance.

Natural persons are treated differently

Being poor is not enough, by itself, to make a court order security for costs against an individual. Courts usually need something extra. This could be living outside the jurisdiction, being a nominal plaintiff (someone suing only in name, with no real stake in the case), or hiding their address.

This stricter approach is deliberate. Unlike a company, an individual has no limited liability protecting them. Courts also weigh heavily against blocking someone’s access to justice.

Individuals who live overseas are treated differently again. Here the worry is not poverty, but whether a costs order could actually be enforced. This depends on whether the plaintiff’s assets are located somewhere that order could reach.

Form, quantum and consequences

Security usually takes the form of money paid into court or a bank guarantee. Courts set the amount using a realistic estimate of the defendant’s costs. This estimate covers costs to a set stage of the case, not the final judgment.

Courts often order security in stages. They revisit the amount as the case moves forward.

If a plaintiff misses the deadline to pay security, the case is usually stayed (paused). Continued failure to pay may lead to dismissal of the case.

This order does not decide who wins on the merits. A plaintiff who later gets funds can apply to lift the stay.

Timing and delay

Apply for security for costs promptly. Delay is a major factor against granting it. Even a strong application can fail if made right before trial.

Security protects a defendant from an unrecoverable costs order. It lets the plaintiff choose whether to keep going on those terms. That choice means little once the plaintiff has already paid for trial preparation, so a late application can look like a tactic.

Courts may still allow a later application if things change. This includes the plaintiff’s financial position worsening, or a funding arrangement coming to light. A party can also apply again for extra security as the case continues.

Litigation funders and third parties

When a litigation funder backs the plaintiff, security for costs is more likely, not less.

Courts check whether the funder has promised to pay any adverse costs order. They also check if that promise is actually worth anything. An offshore funder with no local assets offers little real protection.

Courts have sometimes ordered funders themselves to pay security, even though funders aren’t formal parties to the case. They have also required the funding agreement, or its key terms, to be disclosed for the application.

The same approach applies where the plaintiff is just a nominal party, acting for someone else’s benefit. The court asks who really benefits, and who would really end up paying if costs were awarded against the plaintiff.

Appeals

Courts grant security for costs more easily on appeal than at trial. The party who won at first instance already has a judgment supporting them. The appellant no longer benefits from the presumption of innocence of liability, since that judgment went against them.

The impecuniosity argument also carries less weight on appeal. Impecuniosity means the party cannot afford to pay costs if they lose. This argument matters less here because the appellant already had their chance at a trial.

The stifling consideration is weaker too. This is the worry that ordering security would unfairly block someone from court. Refusing an appellant the means to appeal does not shut them out of justice entirely, since they already had a hearing below.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by working out who the plaintiff is: a corporation, a natural person, or a nominal plaintiff. This decides which power applies and what threshold test you need.

Check the threshold first, before looking at discretion. Note that meeting the threshold does not automatically entitle the defendant to a security for costs order.

Then weigh the discretionary factors together, rather than just listing them. Point out which factor actually decides the outcome on the given facts.

If the plaintiff is impecunious (cannot afford to pay), address stifling directly. This means asking whether the order would stop a genuine claim proceeding, and whether people behind the plaintiff could provide the security instead.

Finally, if the application is made late, discuss that delay. Also suggest a realistic amount of security and the stage of proceedings it should be paid at.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.