Section 92 and interstate trade

The two limbs

Section 92 actually contains two separate guarantees. Courts analyse each one differently.

The first is trade and commerce among the States. This covers commercial activity crossing State borders.

The second is intercourse among the States. This means people and communications moving across borders, even without any commercial element.

These two limbs are not the same rule. A law restricting movement of people engages the intercourse limb, not the trade limb, and courts test it by a different standard.

Trade and commerce: discrimination and protectionism

Quick Read: Section 92 now asks whether a law discriminates against interstate trade in a protectionist way. This came from Cole v Whitfield, which rejected an older “individual rights” approach to s 92.

Two things must both be shown. First, discrimination: the law treats interstate trade worse than local trade, either openly or in practical effect. Second, protectionism: that different treatment actually shields local trade from interstate competition.

If a law burdens interstate and local trade equally, s 92 is not breached, no matter how harsh the burden. In Cole v Whitfield, a crayfish size limit applied to both local and imported crayfish, so it was valid despite affecting interstate traders.

A law can discriminate without breaching s 92, if it has a genuine non-protectionist purpose, like quarantine control on imports. But this is only valid if the discrimination is appropriate and adapted to that purpose, and there is no reasonably available, less discriminatory way to achieve it.

Practical effect

Betfair Pty Ltd v Western Australia (2008) 234 CLR 418 held that discrimination under s 92 depends on a law’s practical effect, not just its wording. A neutral-sounding law can still discriminate if it mainly burdens interstate traders.

Discrimination, protectionism, and justification are separate questions. Showing discrimination does not itself prove the law is protectionist or unjustified.

Betfair also introduced a reasonable necessity test. Where discrimination is claimed to serve a legitimate protective purpose, courts ask if the measure was reasonably necessary for that purpose, and if a less restrictive option existed. Western Australia’s ban on betting exchanges failed this test, since less restrictive rules could have protected integrity.

How far this test applies has since been debated. Palmer v Western Australia (2021) 272 CLR 505 dealt with WA’s COVID-19 border closure. The Court held the Emergency Management Act provisions authorising the directions satisfied s 92 fully, so no constitutional issue arose. However, the Justices disagreed on how to assess justification.

The intercourse limb

The intercourse limb protects the actual crossing of state borders, and communication across them. Courts have not settled its content as clearly as the trade limb.

The core case is a law that burdens interstate movement because of its interstate character. Courts scrutinise such laws closely. Even a law written in general terms can still discriminate against interstate intercourse if that is its practical effect.

The court asks whether a law discriminates against interstate intercourse, either in its wording or its practical effect. If it does discriminate, the court then asks whether that discrimination is justified. In Palmer, each judge treated a differential burden on interstate movement as the starting point for this justification inquiry.

This limb does not give an absolute right to cross a border. Laws about quarantine, public health, and law enforcement may validly restrict movement. Palmer confirms this analysis can accommodate a serious threat to health.

What counts as interstate trade

Section 92 protects trade, commerce and intercourse among the States. This means the movement must actually cross a State border.

A deal entirely inside one State is not protected. This stays true even if it competes with interstate traders. A law about purely local activity does not trigger s 92, even if interstate traders also work there.

Trade with other countries is not covered by s 92 at all. That trade falls under s 51(i) instead.

The guarantee is not limited to selling goods. It also covers services, moving capital, and things like advertising and transport that support a trade deal. A law that burdens a necessary part of interstate trade burdens the trade itself.

Section 92 and the Commonwealth

Section 92 applies to the Commonwealth, not just the States. This gets overlooked because most cases involve state laws.

A Commonwealth law could be invalid if it discriminated against interstate trade in a protectionist sense. But this rarely happens, since the Commonwealth has little reason to favour one State’s industry over another’s. The more realistic issue is the intercourse limb, which protects movement between States. A federal law restricting that movement would need justification.

Section 92 does not give general freedom from Commonwealth economic regulation. A national scheme applying uniformly across Australia is less likely to create a discriminatory burden. Even so, a law applying the same way everywhere can still be checked for discrimination in how it actually operates.

Remedies and standing

If a law breaches s 92, an affected person can ask a court for a declaration of invalidity. This is a court order saying the law has no legal effect. They can also raise s 92 as a defence if prosecuted or facing enforcement action.

Breaching s 92 makes the law invalid, only to the extent it conflicts with s 92. It does not give the trader a right to compensation. Courts may sever or read down the bad part, leaving the rest of the law valid.

Section 92 limits legislative power, rather than granting a personal right. So the real question is always whether the law itself is valid.

A plaintiff need not show their own trade was burdened in some specific way. However, they generally still need standing, meaning a sufficient interest in the matter.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.