Restrictive practices authorisation in Victoria

Step one: authorisation by the Authorised Program Officer

Section 136(1) lets the Authorised Program Officer (the Victorian officer who approves restrictive practices) authorise use, but only if satisfied of three things.

First, under s 136(1)(a), the practice must be “necessary to prevent the person from causing physical harm to themselves or another person.” This is a narrow test: property damage or disruption alone is not enough.

Second, under s 136(1)(b), the practice must be the least restrictive option possible. It must also be included in, and used according to, the person’s behaviour support plan, and must not continue longer than necessary under paragraph (a). So necessity decides both whether the practice is used and for how long.

Third, s 136(1)(c) covers the overlap with the Commonwealth NDIS scheme. If a person gets disability services but lacks a compliant NDIS behaviour support plan, their plan must instead meet the requirements of this Part. This fills the gap left by the Commonwealth rules.

Finally, s 132ZJ shows the Authorised Program Officer is not independent. A provider must get the Senior Practitioner’s approval before appointing one. So the Senior Practitioner controls who can perform step one, in addition to carrying out step two.

Three jurisdictions, three models

Victoria, South Australia and the Commonwealth each handle restrictive practices differently.

In Victoria, an Authorised Program Officer must give authorisation. For seclusion and restraint, the Senior Practitioner must also approve the use. The Senior Practitioner also decides who can become an Authorised Program Officer.

In South Australia, practices are split into two levels. An Authorised Program Officer may authorise level 1 practices. Only the Senior Authorising Officer may authorise level 2 practices. Detention is never a level 1 practice.

The Commonwealth rules ask one consistent question everywhere: was the use authorised under the relevant State or Territory’s own process. Because each jurisdiction answers that question differently, the outcome varies depending on where the practice occurs.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by identifying the type of practice used. Seclusion, physical restraint and mechanical restraint trigger an extra step later in the analysis.

Then test the s 136(1)(a) gateway strictly. It only allows the practice if necessary to prevent physical harm to a person, not to protect property or stop disruption.

Next, work through every part of s 136(1)(b), including its time limit tied to the necessity ground.

If the person has no compliant NDIS behaviour support plan, apply s 136(1)(c) instead.

For seclusion or restraint, Senior Practitioner approval under s 143 is also required, on top of the authorisation itself. Apply the matters set out in s 143(2) when assessing this.

If the practice was used in an emergency, identify which exception is relied on. Deal with the reporting obligation as a separate issue from the authorisation question.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.