Restrictive covenants
Why equity, and why only negative covenants
At common law, the burden of a covenant does not bind later owners of freehold land. If you never promised, you are not bound, no matter how clear the original promise was.
Equity changed this in Tulk v Moxhay. A buyer who takes land with notice of a restriction their predecessor agreed to cannot in good conscience ignore it.
This equitable intervention is based on conscience, which limits what it can do. Equity can stop a buyer doing something (a negative duty), but cannot force them to do something they never agreed to. This means the burden of a positive covenant -- like repairing or paying for upkeep -- does not pass to new owners.
Whether a covenant is positive or negative depends on substance, not wording. A covenant to “keep land open” is negative, despite sounding positive. A covenant “not to let a fence fall into disrepair” is positive, despite sounding negative.
The real test: does following the covenant require the owner to spend money? If yes, it is positive, and its burden will not run with the land.
The benefit: annexation, assignment, scheme
A successor to the benefited land must show a right to enforce the covenant. There are three ways to do this.
Annexation attaches the benefit to the land when the covenant is made. This means it passes automatically when the land is transferred. It can be express, or implied from the covenant’s wording, and some jurisdictions have statutes that assume annexation unless it is excluded.
Assignment transfers the benefit with the land each time it changes hands. This needs an unbroken chain of assignments, and this is usually where such claims fail.
A building scheme arises where lots are sold under a common plan with mutually enforceable restrictions. Here, each lot owner can enforce the restrictions against any other owner, regardless of sale order. The requirements are strict: a common vendor, a defined area, restrictions meant to be mutually enforceable, and purchasers who bought on that understanding.
Modification and extinguishment
A covenant can end in a few ways. It may be released expressly, where the parties agree to end it. It can also be extinguished if one person comes to own both the benefited and burdened land.
Most jurisdictions also allow courts to modify or discharge a covenant under a statutory power. Common grounds include that the covenant is obsolete due to changes in the neighbourhood’s character. Another ground is that the covenant blocks reasonable use of land without giving any real, substantial benefit. Courts may also act if those who hold the benefit have agreed to its removal, or have acquiesced (stayed silent and let things happen).
Equity can also refuse to enforce a covenant for ordinary discretionary reasons. These include delay, acquiescence, or widespread breach of the covenant in the area. If breach is widespread, enforcing it against just one owner may be unfair.
Enforcement and remedies
Quick Read: Enforcement and remedies
The main remedy for breach of a restrictive covenant is an injunction. This is a court order stopping the breach. Courts use this because the covenant is negative and equity enforces such promises directly.
Sometimes courts award damages instead. This happens only if the breach is trivial, the harm can be measured in money, a small payment would fairly compensate it, and an injunction would be too harsh.
Timing matters a lot. If a covenantee delays while building goes ahead, they may lose the right to an injunction and get only damages, or nothing at all, due to laches and acquiescence (waiting too long or appearing to accept the breach). Seeking urgent interlocutory relief early is often crucial, since a finished building limits what remedy a court will give.
Where the real dispute is about interpretation, a declaration is often more useful. This is a court statement clarifying whether a covenant binds certain land, or what it means.
Construction
Courts read restrictive covenants like ordinary contracts. They look at the whole scheme and the circumstances when the covenant was made.
If a covenant is ambiguous, this does not automatically favour the covenantee (the person benefiting from the restriction). But courts still won’t stretch the covenant’s words beyond what they clearly mean.
Where a covenant refers to a standard existing when it was created — like building materials or floor area — that original standard applies. Current practice is irrelevant.
Whether a covenant is negative in substance is itself a question of interpretation. A covenant to use land “only as a private dwelling” counts as negative, even though it’s worded positively, because obeying it just means not doing other things.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by working out if the covenant is negative or positive in substance. If it is positive, say so clearly. For a positive covenant, the burden does not run to successors, and the analysis stops there.
If the covenant is negative, go through the four burden requirements one by one. Work out which requirement is actually in dispute.
Next, look at the benefit separately. Check whether it passes by annexation, assignment, or scheme. Do not assume someone can enforce the covenant just because they own land nearby.
Under the Torrens system, check whether the covenant is recorded on the title. Then check what the relevant Act says that recording actually achieves.
Finally, consider two possible outs. There may be a statutory power to modify the covenant. There may also be equitable discretionary bars — reasons a court could refuse to enforce it, such as changed neighbourhood character or long acquiescence (the claimant waiting too long without objecting).
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.