Res judicata, issue estoppel and Anshun estoppel
What they have in common
All three doctrines share three basic requirements.
First, there must be a final judgment. Interlocutory decisions, meaning orders made without a ruling on the merits, usually do not create an estoppel. A consent judgment may still count, though.
Second, the judgment must come from a court of competent jurisdiction. This means a court with proper authority to decide the case.
Third, the parties in both cases must be the same, or be privies of each other. Privity means having a real interest in the earlier case’s subject matter, like a successor in title, an assignee, or someone the case was brought to benefit. Simply sharing a common interest is not enough to count as privity.
Issue estoppel
Issue estoppel can arise even when the causes of action are different. It applies when a specific issue was already decided in an earlier case. That earlier decision then binds the parties later.
Blair v Curran (1939) 62 CLR 464 limits how far this goes. The estoppel only covers matters that were legally indispensable to the earlier decision. These are the ultimate facts that formed the essential elements of that cause of action.
It does not cover the court’s reasoning process, minor evidentiary findings, or collateral comments, even if stated firmly. So working out exactly what was decided is often the hardest part of an issue estoppel argument. If the earlier judgment does not show which ground supported the decision, no estoppel arises on any of them.
Unlike cause of action estoppel, issue estoppel can give way in special circumstances. This happens notably where new evidence, not reasonably available earlier, would have changed the outcome.
Anshun estoppel
Anshun estoppel comes from the case Port of Melbourne Authority v Anshun Pty Ltd. It covers things that were never actually argued in court before.
The rule: you cannot raise a claim or defence later if it was so connected to the earlier case that it was unreasonable not to raise it then.
The key question is unreasonableness, not just whether you could have raised it. Courts look at whether the new claim comes from the same facts, whether raising it earlier was practical, and whether it risks conflicting judgments. Conflicting judgments is treated as especially important. Courts also weigh the cost and hassle of a second case.
This doctrine is discretionary, meaning courts use judgment rather than a fixed rule. If someone genuinely did not know about the claim, or could not have raised it earlier, the estoppel does not apply.
Abuse of process
Sometimes the estoppels discussed above don’t apply. This can happen if the parties are not the same, or the earlier case did not end in a judgment.
Even then, courts can still stay (pause or stop) a case as an abuse of process. This covers collateral attacks, where someone not involved in a case tries to challenge its outcome. It also covers serial proceedings that are oppressive, meaning repeated cases that unfairly burden a party.
This power is residual, meaning it applies only when other rules don’t. Courts use it sparingly. Its purpose is to protect the integrity of the justice system, not to enforce the rights of the specific parties involved.
Consent and default judgments
A consent judgment is one both parties agree to, instead of a court deciding the case. It can still found a cause of action estoppel, because the cause of action merges into the judgment regardless of how the judgment came about.
Whether it founds an issue estoppel is less clear, since nothing was actually decided. Any estoppel here usually comes from the settlement terms themselves, treated as a contract, or from the parties’ agreement not to revisit the matter.
A default judgment arises when one side fails to respond, and the court rules without a contest. It also ends the cause of action, but does not support an issue estoppel, since no issue was actually litigated. It can still be set aside on normal grounds, and no estoppel can rely on a judgment that is being challenged.
A judgment obtained by fraud may be set aside entirely. No estoppel survives once such a judgment is overturned.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.