Damages as a remedy

Choose the measure before calculating money

First, work out which legal interest was harmed, and what performance or position the claimant lost. For a broken promise about property, the right measure may be the cost of fixing the property to match the promise, not just the fall in its market value.

Tabcorp Holdings Ltd v Bowen Investments Pty Ltd shows this. The court allowed the cost of rectification (fixing the property) for breach of a covenant (a contractual promise) about a commercial foyer.

The real question is not “what feels fair?” It is whether the sum compensates the specific loss, without overcompensating the claimant. A different remedy, like an injunction or restitution, protects a different interest and needs separate analysis.

One set of facts can give rise to several causes of action, but the claimant cannot recover twice for the same loss. A good answer explains both contract and tort measures, making clear what each one compensates.

It should also separate a claim for debt (a fixed sum owed under the contract) from a claim for damages (compensation for loss caused by breach). These labels can change the questions asked about proof, mitigation and interest.

Test the limits on recovery

Four questions usually guide a damages analysis.

First, causation. Did the breach or wrong actually cause the loss? If the loss would have happened anyway, you cannot recover it from this defendant.

Second, remoteness or scope. Does this type of loss fall within what the rule or promise was meant to cover? Contract and tort ask this differently, so match the test to the right cause of action.

Third, mitigation. Did the claimant act reasonably to avoid loss that could be avoided? Reasonable steps to mitigate, even if they cost money, can themselves be claimed back. The claimant need not take unreasonable risks or spend unreasonably to mitigate.

Fourth, proof and valuation. Has the claimant proved the loss and shown a rational basis for the amount claimed? Loss being hard to value does not defeat a claim, but mere speculation will.

These four questions work together, not alone. A loss can be caused by the breach yet still fail because it is too remote, avoidable, or unproven.

It helps to separate past loss from future loss. Past loss is usually proved with records of what already happened. Future loss needs a reasoned estimate, accounting for contingencies, not a guess.

Do not overlook statutory rules

Damages rules are not only common law. Statutes can change things like what losses you can claim, caps on damages, interest, time limits, contributory negligence, and other remedies available.

Before stating a cap or threshold, name the statute and jurisdiction it comes from. Rules can differ between jurisdictions.

Treat the general common law framework as a starting point only. It cannot replace the specific statutory regime that applies.

Keep the remedy proportionate to the loss

Damages should match the loss, not punish the defendant or reward the claimant.

If a right is breached but no real loss is shown, the claimant may get nominal damages. This means a small, token sum.

But if a substantial loss is shown, a large award can still be proper. This applies even if exact figures are hard to calculate.

Some awards called “damages” work differently. Exemplary damages, where available, punish the defendant rather than compensate the claimant.

Aggravated damages are compensatory, but they reflect extra harm caused by how the wrong was done.

Do not assume these apply in an ordinary breach-of-contract case. Also check for statutory limits in negligence and personal-injury claims.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.