Related-party transactions

The basic rule

A public company (or an entity it controls) can only give a financial benefit to a related party if one of two conditions is met.

Either the members have approved the benefit using the proper statutory procedure, and the benefit is given within 15 months of that approval. Or the benefit fits within one of the recognised exceptions.

This rule does not apply to proprietary companies. Chapter 2E simply does not operate for them.

Directors of proprietary companies still owe their general duties. They must also still avoid conflicts of interest under the statutory duty, even though Chapter 2E itself does not apply.

What is a financial benefit

“Financial benefit” is a broad concept. Any doubt about whether something counts gets resolved in favour of it being a financial benefit.

It covers many things: giving finance or property, buying or selling an asset, leasing, supplying or receiving services, issuing securities, and taking on an obligation.

The law looks at the economic and commercial substance of what happened. It ignores what was paid in return. This means even a deal done on full commercial terms still counts as giving a financial benefit. Whether fair value was paid is a separate question, dealt with under the arm’s length exception.

Benefits given indirectly, through other entities placed in between, are also caught.

Who is a related party

Related parties include company directors, and directors of any entity that controls the company.

They also include the spouses of those directors, and the parents and children of those directors and spouses.

Entities controlled by a related party count too. So do entities that control the public company itself.

Finally, someone counts as a related party if they held that status in the last six months. A person also counts if they believe, on reasonable grounds, that they will become one.

The approval procedure

Members must approve the transaction by resolution at a general meeting. The rules here are strict. Breaking them is itself a contravention, meaning a breach of the law.

The company must lodge the draft notice of meeting with ASIC fourteen days before sending it out. The notice must name the related party, describe the benefit, and include all information the company or directors know that members would reasonably need to decide if the deal suits the company.

The related party and their associates generally cannot vote on the resolution, though narrow exceptions apply. The resolution must pass exactly as proposed, with no material changes.

Disclosure is the key obligation in this area. Companies often get independent expert reports for major transactions, and leaving one out can invite legal challenge if the missing information mattered.

Contravention and consequences

Here’s the key point: the company itself does not break the law, and the deal still stands. Chapter 2E does not unwind dealings with outsiders.

Instead, it’s the people involved who contravene — usually the directors who approved it. This can mean civil penalties, and if they acted dishonestly, criminal liability too.

These rules work alongside the general duties, not instead of them. Even if a deal fits an exception, it might still breach the duty of care, the duty to act in good faith, or the duty not to misuse position. Claims are often based on these duties instead.

Listing rule overlays

If you’re on the ASX, Chapter 2E is not enough on its own. The ASX Listing Rules add their own rules for related-party and substantial-holder transactions.

These Listing Rules do not match the statute exactly. The definitions, thresholds and approval triggers can all differ. Sometimes the Listing Rules need shareholder approval even when Chapter 2E does not.

Listed entities also have continuous disclosure duties. A material related-party transaction is usually price-sensitive, so it generally needs immediate disclosure. This applies regardless of whether member approval is also required.

So there are three separate checks: Chapter 2E, then the Listing Rules, then disclosure. Each asks a different question and can give a different answer.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by checking the company type. The rules only apply to a public company, or an entity it controls.

Next, find the financial benefit. Read this widely, looking at the real economic effect, not just the label.

Then work out if a related-party relationship exists. Check each specific limb, including the six-month look-back period.

Before worrying about approval, check the exceptions. If one applies, no approval is needed at all.

If approval was sought, look closely at the disclosure given and any voting exclusions that applied.

Work out who contravenes the rules. Note that the transaction itself still stands, regardless of any contravention.

Finally, deal with the general directors’ duties as a separate issue.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.