Ratio, obiter and material facts

Start with the dispute actually decided

Start by figuring out the actual dispute the court decided.

Ask four questions. What facts mattered legally? What legal issue needed resolving? What rule did the court apply? What order resulted?

Material facts explain why the rule worked as it did. In negligence, this might mean the parties’ relationship, the risk involved, the defendant’s conduct and the harm caused.

In statutory cases, material facts might mean the decision-maker, the power used, the statute’s wording and the procedural step said to be invalid.

Worked example: extracting a ratio

Here’s a worked example. A court upholds a decision made under a statute, even though a procedural step was not followed exactly.

The ratio, meaning the binding legal rule, is not “procedural steps do not matter”. That would be too broad.

A better statement is narrower. Invalidity depends on whether the legislature intended non-compliance to invalidate the act. Courts assess this through text, context and purpose.

This narrower statement is more useful. It states the legal test clearly, while leaving room for a different outcome if the statute, purpose or consequence differs.

Plurality, concurrence and dissent

Australian appeal courts often give more than one set of reasons. Judges might agree on the outcome but reach it differently.

Check the orders first. Then work out which judges support which reasons. A joint judgment, where judges write together, is usually simpler to follow. A split court needs closer reading.

A dissent is a judge’s disagreement with the majority outcome. It does not count as the ratio, the binding legal rule of the case. But a dissent can still shape later cases, and it shows the legal arguments the majority rejected.

High Court dicta

Quick Read: High Court dicta

High Court decisions sometimes include comments that are not strictly needed to decide the case. These are called obiter dicta. Even so, some of this obiter carries real weight.

In Farah Constructions Pty Ltd v Say-Dee Pty Ltd, the Court called some of this “seriously considered dicta”. Do not dismiss a High Court comment just by labelling it obiter.

Instead, ask whether the comment was central to the Court’s reasoning, carefully considered, repeated, and connected to your issue.

It is unsettled whether this rule about seriously considered dicta has one requirement or two. In Harvard Nominees Pty Ltd v Tiller, the Full Federal Court favoured a narrower view with two requirements: the dicta must match long-established authority, and must come from a majority of the High Court.

This view comes from an intermediate appellate court, not the High Court itself. The Court said the High Court has not settled this question. Cite this view as the Federal Court’s position, not as settled High Court law.

Self-check

Before you use a case, test yourself on six things in one sentence each.

State the material facts, the legal issue, and the ratio (the binding reason for the decision).

Then note any important obiter (comments made in passing, not binding), the court and its place in the hierarchy, and why the case binds, persuades, or merely illustrates your problem.

Doing this turns reading into real legal reasoning. It stops citations becoming mere decoration added after you have already guessed the answer.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.