Title

Title as a bundle of rights

Ownership is not one single right. Lawyers describe it as a bundle of rights. These include possessing, using, excluding others, earning income, selling or mortgaging, and consuming or destroying the thing.

Title means holding that bundle, or part of it, over something. You can hold title to less than full ownership. A lease, a mortgage, or an easement are each examples of partial interests with their own title.

Because title is a bundle, it can be split between people. An owner may hold the freehold (full ownership of the land) while a tenant holds a leasehold title. A bank may also hold a mortgagee’s title over the same land as security.

Each of these titles is a real property right. This means each can generally be enforced against third parties, not just against the other party to that transaction.

Title and possession compared

Possession is just actual control over something. It’s protected because the legal system works better when we respect things as they are.

Title is different. It’s a stronger, more abstract right. You can hold title to land or goods without ever touching them or currently possessing them.

Sometimes title and possession split between two people. A mortgagor keeps possession of land, even though a bank holds a registered mortgage. A bailee possesses goods belonging to a bailor.

When this happens, title decides who wins if the dispute goes all the way. But possession decides who wins for now, against anyone with a weaker claim.

Proving title: general law and registration

Outside registration schemes, title is proved by a chain of title. This is a sequence of documents tracing ownership back to a root of title.

Every document in the chain must be validly executed. A hidden defect anywhere can undermine later owners’ title, even honest buyers who paid full value. Checking a chain of title is slow and never completely risk-free.

Registration systems fix this by making the register itself the source of title. In Breskvar v Wall, the court described this as the register giving title its own “currency”. Once an interest is registered, a person dealing with the registered owner can generally trust the register, without checking its history.

For land, this is the Torrens system, covered in a companion article. For personal property security interests, the Personal Property Securities Register serves a similar role. Both systems base title on a public record, not a private chain of documents, subject to defined exceptions.

Why the distinction matters

Quick Read: Why the distinction matters

How a person’s rights arise matters a lot. Rights can come from title shown by a chain of documents, from registration, or from possession alone.

This source affects what must be pleaded and proved in a dispute. It also affects what searches a purchaser needs to do, and what defences apply if someone acquired an interest without knowing of a competing claim.

Working out the source of title is usually the first step in solving any property problem.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by working out what interest is being argued over. Ask whether it is title, meaning a proprietary right, or just a personal claim.

Next, check if the property falls under a registration scheme. If it does, ask whether the interest in question has actually been registered.

If registration does not apply, or the dispute is about unregistered dealings, trace the chain of title. Look for any defect in that chain and work out who it affects.

Separate the party who holds title from the party who merely holds possession. Explain what each can and cannot do, both against each other and against third parties.

Finally, say whether the answer turns on strong documentary title, on registration, or on possession alone. Give reasons for that choice.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.