Mortgages

A mortgage is security, not a transfer of ownership

At general law, a mortgage of land was a conveyance, meaning the borrower (mortgagor) transferred their estate to the lender (mortgagee). This transfer was defeasible, meaning it could be undone if the borrower repaid on time. Strictly, the lender became legal owner, and the borrower’s right to reclaim the land was only contractual.

Equity stepped in to protect borrowers. It recognised an ongoing right to redeem the land even after the repayment date passed. This is called the equity of redemption, covered later.

Under the Torrens system, this changes completely by statute. A registered mortgage does not transfer the mortgagor’s estate to the mortgagee at all. The mortgagor stays the registered proprietor throughout.

Instead, the mortgage operates as a registered charge or encumbrance on the title. This gives the mortgagee statutory powers and priority, without giving them ownership. Calling a Torrens mortgage a transfer of ownership is a common student mistake to avoid.

The mortgagee’s remedies on default

When a mortgagor defaults, for example by missing a payment or breaking another term, the mortgagee has several main remedies.

The mortgagee can sue for the debt. This is an ordinary claim for the money owed, since the mortgage secures a personal promise to pay, not just an interest in the land.

The mortgagee can also take possession of the property. This right generally exists even without default, but is usually limited by the mortgage terms, by consumer protection laws for home loans, and by mortgagees’ own reluctance to take on the duties possession brings.

Another remedy is the power of sale, the one most often used. The mortgagee sells the property, pays the debt and costs from the proceeds, and returns any surplus to the mortgagor. This power must be used in good faith and with reasonable care about price, as established in Forsyth v Blundell. The power comes from statute or from the mortgage document read together with statute, under each jurisdiction’s Torrens legislation. It only arises once set preconditions are met, such as a required period of default and proper notice, and these details differ between jurisdictions and must be followed exactly.

The mortgagee may also appoint a receiver. This is more common for mortgages over income-producing property or business assets. The receiver collects income and manages the property until it is sold.

Finally, foreclosure once let a mortgagee take full ownership of the property, ending the mortgagor’s right to redeem it. This remedy still exists in a limited, rarely used form under Torrens legislation, but the power of sale is now the remedy mortgagees actually use.

The equity of redemption

The equity of redemption is a borrower’s right to pay off the mortgage debt and get the property back. This right survives even after the repayment date passes.

The right lasts until the lender has completed a valid sale or foreclosure. Foreclosure means the lender taking the property outright, ending the borrower’s rights.

Equity (the court’s fairness-based rules) treats this right as part of the deal itself. The parties cannot remove it through their contract terms.

A clause that makes redemption illusory, or gives the lender extra benefits beyond debt and costs, may be struck down. This is called a clog on the equity of redemption.

However, commercial mortgages between sophisticated parties get more flexibility in how they are structured.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by checking the mortgage is over Torrens land. The mortgagor stays the registered proprietor, since a mortgage is only a charge, not a transfer of title.

Next, check whether default has happened. If the mortgagee wants to use the power of sale, check the statutory preconditions are met — the right default period and proper notice, under that jurisdiction’s legislation.

Then work out which remedy or remedies suit the facts. Explain what each remedy does and what it requires to use it.

Check whether any mortgage term improperly restricts or defeats the mortgagor’s equity of redemption (their right to get the property back by paying off the debt).

Finally, trace where sale proceeds go. The mortgagee must account to the mortgagor for any surplus left after the debt and proper costs are paid.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.