Leases

Lease versus licence: exclusive possession

The key test for telling a lease apart from a licence is exclusive possession. This comes from Radaich v Smith (1959). Exclusive possession means the occupier can exclude everyone, even the landlord, except for rights the landlord has kept, like entering to inspect or repair.

If an occupier has exclusive possession for a set term, it is a lease. This is true no matter what the document is called.

If the occupier only has a personal right to use the premises, shared with the owner or others, and cannot exclude the owner, it is a licence. This applies even if the document is headed “lease”.

The distinction matters because a lease is a proprietary interest. It generally survives a sale of the land and can be registered on the Torrens register. Shorter leases may take effect without registration, as an exception to indefeasibility in most jurisdictions.

A licence is different. It only binds the people who made it. It does not survive a sale to a new owner who does not know about it and has not agreed to honour it.

Essential requirements of a lease

A valid lease needs four things. First, the parties and the premises must be clearly identifiable. The land, or the part of it leased, must be certain enough to describe.

Second, the tenant needs exclusive possession. This is what separates a tenant from a mere licensee, as explained earlier.

Third, the lease needs certainty of term. You must be able to work out the maximum length of the lease from the start, whether it is a fixed term, a periodic tenancy (one that renews automatically each rent period, like weekly or monthly, until properly ended), or a tenancy at will. If the term depends on an uncertain event with no outer limit, it risks being void for uncertainty under general law. Some jurisdictions have changed this strict rule by statute for certain situations.

Fourth, both parties must consent to the lease, under the ordinary rules for forming any legal relationship.

Rent is not strictly required for a valid lease under modern Australian law. Still, rent is almost always present in practice, and its absence can suggest the parties never intended to create a proprietary interest at all.

Formalities

A lease is an interest in land. So creating one usually follows the same formality rules as other land dealings, though these rules vary by jurisdiction.

Longer leases often need to be in writing. A common exempted term is three years, but the exact cutoff and the law behind it differ between jurisdictions.

Longer leases may also need registration under the relevant Torrens statute.

Short leases are often treated differently. They can usually be created informally, even orally, because they matter less economically.

Core obligations

Unless the parties agree otherwise, or statute overrides it, the general law implies core obligations into every lease.

The landlord must give the tenant quiet enjoyment. This means freedom from substantial interference with possession, by the landlord or anyone claiming through them. Depending on the premises and jurisdiction, the landlord may also owe duties about fitness for habitation or repair.

The tenant must pay the agreed rent, use the premises consistently with the lease, and avoid waste or damage beyond fair wear and tear. The tenant must also yield up possession when the term ends.

Residential tenancies get extra protection under state and territory tenancy legislation. This covers things like bond handling, termination notice periods, and minimum premises standards. These schemes differ between jurisdictions, so a rule from one state’s statute cannot be assumed to apply elsewhere.

Applying this in a problem question

First, ignore what the parties called the arrangement. Ask whether the occupier actually has exclusive possession — the right to keep everyone else out, including the owner.

If there is no exclusive possession, the arrangement is a licence, not a lease. Then ask separately whether that licence binds a third party at all.

If exclusive possession exists, check the other requirements for a valid lease. Certainty of term matters most — the lease must have a fixed or calculable end date.

Next, check whether any formality, like writing or registration, was required for this type of term in this jurisdiction. Confirm whether that formality was actually satisfied.

Finally, match the facts to the relevant obligation — quiet enjoyment, repair, rent, or yielding up possession. Also consider whether jurisdiction-specific residential or retail tenancy legislation changes the general law position.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.