Professional discipline

The two levels of conduct

There are two levels of lawyer misconduct.

Unsatisfactory professional conduct is the lower level. It means conduct in legal practice that falls short of what the public expects from a reasonably competent lawyer. The test is objective, and even one careless act can count.

Professional misconduct is more serious. It includes unsatisfactory conduct that is substantial or repeated, and also any conduct showing the lawyer is not a fit and proper person to practise.

This second type can include conduct outside legal practice. Dishonesty in your personal life can still count, because it reflects on your character and fitness to practise. This focus on fitness is why misconduct findings, unlike unsatisfactory conduct findings, can lead to removal from the roll.

Some conduct is automatically treated by statute as one of these categories. Examples include being convicted of a serious offence, becoming insolvent, breaching an order, or breaching trust account rules.

Orders

Orders from an authority are corrective, not career-ending. They include a caution or reprimand, compensation up to a set limit, extra education, supervision, redoing work for free, or a modest fine.

Orders from a tribunal can affect whether someone can keep practising. These include conditions on the practising certificate, suspension, a bigger fine, or, where fitness to practise is the issue, a recommendation for removal from the roll.

The tribunal cannot actually strike a practitioner off. Under Legal Profession Uniform Law s 302(1)(f), it can only recommend removal. The Supreme Court alone removes a name from its roll, using its inherent power over its own officers.

Removal is not punishment for past conduct. It asks whether the practitioner is presently fit and proper to practise.

Who regulates

Most Australian jurisdictions use the Legal Profession Uniform Law or similar legislation. This splits regulation across three bodies.

A local regulatory authority, such as a Law Society or Legal Services Commissioner, handles complaints and investigations. It may deal with minor matters itself.

A designated tribunal hears serious matters. It makes orders affecting a lawyer’s right to practise.

The Supreme Court keeps its own separate power over lawyers, called inherent jurisdiction. This power exists outside the statute and cannot be taken away by it.

This inherent jurisdiction matters when the statutory scheme does not cover certain conduct. It is also the source of the court’s power to strike a practitioner off the roll.

The purpose is protective, not punitive

Disciplinary law protects the public and keeps trust in the profession. It does not exist to punish the practitioner.

This means two things. For serious cases, the test is whether the practitioner is still a fit and proper person. This is judged at the hearing date, not when the conduct happened. So insight, rehabilitation and changed circumstances matter.

Orders are picked for their protective effect, not as punishment. A supervision condition may be used instead of suspension if it manages the risk.

Because the aim is protective, normal criminal law protections do not fully apply. Disciplinary action can follow a criminal acquittal on the same facts without breaching double jeopardy (being punished twice for the same act).

Conduct outside practice

Conduct outside legal practice can still count against a practitioner. This happens where it shows they are not a fit and proper person. Common examples include dishonesty offences, serious violence, and tax evasion.

Statutes also list conduct that is capable of being unsatisfactory professional conduct or professional misconduct. Examples include conviction of a serious offence, conviction of a tax offence, insolvency under administration, and disqualification from managing a corporation.

Being on this list does not make a finding automatic. The tribunal still must assess whether the practitioner is fit and proper.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by working out the jurisdiction. Check whether the Uniform Law or a state Act applies.

Then characterise the conduct. Test it against both definitions, and explain why it fits one category rather than just naming the more serious one.

Ask whether the conduct happened in connection with practice. If not, consider whether it still affects fitness to practise.

Next, trace the procedure. This runs from complaint, to a possible consumer matter, then investigation, then a determination or tribunal hearing.

Finally, match the orders to the right forum. Do not say the regulatory authority removed someone from the roll.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.