Private nuisance

Who may sue, and what is protected

To sue in private nuisance, you need an interest in the land affected. This means freeholders and tenants in possession can sue.

A family member, guest or licensee without possessory rights generally cannot sue. Oldham v Lawson (No 1) [1976] VR 654 confirms this limit in Australia.

This proprietary character (meaning the tort protects rights in land, not just personal rights) is the key structural difference from negligence. Negligence only asks whether the defendant owed this particular claimant a duty.

The interference can take three forms: physical damage to land, interference with comfort and convenience, or encroachment. Most case law concerns the second type, covering things like noise, smell, smoke, vibration and light.

This is because courts must draw a difficult line here. They must distinguish ordinary life’s inconveniences from interference that is legally actionable.

What makes an interference unreasonable

Not every interference counts as a nuisance. Courts ask if it was substantial and unreasonable, judged objectively rather than by how sensitive the claimant is. Several factors help decide this question together.

Locality matters: what counts as reasonable in an industrial area differs from a residential street. How long, how often, and when the interference happens also matters. A single short event rarely qualifies, but ongoing night-time noise often does. In Munro v Southern Dairies, noise, smell and flies from dairy horses were found to be a nuisance, and the court accepted that losing even one night’s sleep can be substantial.

A claimant with an unusually sensitive use of their land cannot recover just for that extra sensitivity. If the defendant acted with malice, meaning deliberately to annoy, courts more readily find the conduct unreasonable. The social usefulness of the defendant’s activity is relevant, but it is not a defence. A useful activity carried out unreasonably is still a nuisance.

Locality does not excuse actual physical damage to land. This distinction comes from St Helen’s Smelting Co v Tipping, and Australian courts still apply it. So a defendant cannot rely on an area’s industrial character to answer a claim for damaged crops or corroded paintwork.

Who is liable

Whoever creates a nuisance is liable for it.

An occupier can also be liable if they adopt or continue a nuisance someone else created. This covers nuisances started by a predecessor, a trespasser, or nature itself. Liability attaches once the occupier knows, or should know, about it and fails to take reasonable steps to fix it (Sedleigh-Denfield v O’Callaghan).

This is why a landowner can be liable for a deteriorating retaining wall or blocked drain they inherited. It’s a common turning point in problem questions.

You don’t need fault in the negligence sense to be liable. But it isn’t strict liability either — the kind of harm caused must have been reasonably foreseeable.

So a defendant won’t be liable for a completely unforeseeable result of an otherwise lawful use of their land.

Defences, and what does not work

The strongest defence is statutory authority. If legislation authorises the activity, and the nuisance is bound to happen when carrying it out, there is no liability. Courts must work out whether the legislature truly authorised the activity, or just allowed it subject to the ordinary law.

Prescription can give a right to continue a nuisance after twenty years. This is hard to prove, because the twenty years only counts while the interference is an actionable nuisance. Consent, and in most places statutory contributory negligence (where the claimant’s own carelessness reduces their damages), may also be defences.

Two common arguments do not work. Coming to the nuisance -- moving in already knowing about the activity -- is no defence at common law. Some statutes protect specific activities though; in Tasmania, qualifying primary industry activities on farmland are protected from being treated as a nuisance.

Public benefit is not a defence either. That many people benefit from the defendant’s activity might affect what remedy the court gives, but it does not excuse liability.

Remedies, and the choice between them

Damages are money paid to cover the drop in the land’s value or amenity, plus any flow-on losses.

If the nuisance keeps happening, the main remedy is an injunction, a court order stopping the conduct. Australian courts usually prefer this over damages, so a defendant cannot just pay to keep wronging someone.

Abatement means fixing the problem yourself. This option is narrow and risky, so it is rarely good advice.

Public nuisance is different: it harms a whole group, not just one landowner. A person can only sue over it if they suffered special damage, worse than the harm to the public generally.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by checking the claimant’s interest in the land. Someone in possession can usually sue. A reversioner (a person with a future right to the land) can sue too, but only if the nuisance is permanent enough to damage that future interest. A mere licensee cannot sue, no matter how strong the complaint.

Next, characterise the interference. Is it physical damage, or interference with comfort and convenience? If it’s physical damage, locality matters less.

Then weigh the unreasonableness factors together, not one by one. Say which factors matter most on the facts, and explain why.

Identify the defendant precisely. Are they the creator of the nuisance, or an occupier who adopted or continued a nuisance they knew or should have known about?

Consider statutory authority if relevant legislation applies. Also deal directly with “coming to the nuisance” and public benefit arguments, if the facts raise them.

Finally, choose the remedy. Explain why an injunction is or isn’t suitable, rather than assuming damages are the answer.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.