Precedent in Australian law
Ratio decidendi and obiter dicta
Two key terms come up often: ratio decidendi and obiter dicta. The ratio decidendi is the legal reasoning the court needed to reach its decision.
Obiter dicta are other comments the court makes that are not necessary to the decision. These can still be useful, especially from a top court, but they do not automatically bind later courts the way the ratio does.
Finding the ratio is often hard. Courts rarely state it as a single clear sentence.
Students usually must work it out themselves. The key question is: what legal rule did the court need, to reach this result on these facts?
Vertical and horizontal precedent
Vertical precedent is about hierarchy between courts. A lower court must follow binding decisions of a higher court in the same hierarchy. High Court decisions bind courts across all of Australia.
Horizontal precedent is different. It concerns how a court treats its own past decisions, or decisions of courts at the same level. This is usually more flexible, but courts still cannot ignore it casually.
A state trial judge must follow High Court decisions. A single judge of the Federal Court will usually follow another single judge’s decision, unless satisfied it is plainly wrong. The exact rule still depends on the court and context.
An intermediate appellate court faces a stricter task. It must handle both its own past decisions and High Court authority with particular care.
Following, distinguishing and overruling
Following means a court applies the same rule. This happens when the facts and legal issue are close enough to an earlier case.
Distinguishing is different. The court accepts the earlier case is correct, but finds a material difference. That difference changes the result in the new case.
Overruling is different again. It happens when a higher court says an earlier legal rule is no longer correct.
Reversing is not the same as overruling. It means an appellate court changes the result in the same litigation.
Reversing does not always mean every principle in the lower judgment is overruled for future cases. Students should still check the appellate court’s reasons carefully.
Majority, plurality and dissent
When judges give fragmented reasons, check if they agree on the reasoning, not just the result. Sometimes there’s no single majority path (a plurality). Don’t oversimplify: say which judges held what, and state only the narrowest point the case actually supports.
A dissent (a judge’s disagreeing reasons) is never the ratio, the binding part of a decision. But dissents can still help explain competing arguments or unsettled areas.
Courts disagree on whether a rule has one or two requirements. In Harvard Nominees v Tiller (2020), the Full Federal Court preferred the narrower reading: dicta (comments not strictly necessary to the decision) are only binding if they fit long-established authority and come from a majority of the High Court. The court admitted the High Court hasn’t settled this. Cite this as one court’s view, not as settled law.
Aristocrat Technologies v Commissioner of Patents [2025] FCAFC 131 confirms this two-requirement approach. It also warns against a common mistake: you cannot build a “majority” by combining a dissenting judge’s reasons with part of the majority’s. Judges agreeing on the outcome isn’t the same as agreeing on the reasoning.
A related rule covers departing from another intermediate appellate court’s decision. In Lendlease Corporation v Pallas [2025] HCA 19, Edelman J said such courts should generally follow the earlier court’s ratio decidendi (binding reasoning) on national legislation, unless convinced it’s plainly wrong. This was only one judge’s view, though the rest of the Court didn’t disturb it.
Self-check
Before using a precedent, ask a few questions first.
Is it binding, persuasive, or just illustrative? Has it been followed or distinguished later? Is the part you’re relying on the ratio (the binding reasoning) or obiter (comments not essential to the decision)?
Also check whether your facts are close enough to make the comparison honest.
For more on this, see the articles on ratio, obiter and material facts, reading cases with purpose, and legal reasoning and problem solving.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.