Enduring documents and advance health directives in Queensland

When a direction operates

Section 36(1) of this Queensland law sets two rules. First, a direction in an advance health directive only operates while the principal has impaired capacity for that matter.

Second, once it operates, the law treats it as if the principal gave the direction right then, with capacity. This second rule is what makes the directive powerful.

The direction is not an old wish to be weighed up later. It is treated as a decision made by a capable person at the time it matters.

Section 35(4) confirms the directive is not revoked just because the principal becomes impaired. In fact, that impairment is the very event that makes the directive start operating.

Section 35(5) lets an adult principal outside Queensland make an advance health directive.

Priority over an attorney

Section 35(3) says an advance health directive’s directions beat an attorney’s power for health matters.

If a principal has both an enduring power of attorney and a directive, there is no real conflict. The directive controls where it gives a direction. The attorney’s power fills the gaps where the directive is silent.

Section 36(3) limits the attorney’s power under a directive. The attorney can only act when the principal has impaired capacity for that matter, and not otherwise.

When the attorney’s power does apply, s 36(4) lets the attorney do what the principal could lawfully do with capacity. This is subject to the directive’s terms and the Act, per s 36(5). Section 36(6) lets someone dealing with the attorney ask for proof of impaired capacity, such as a medical certificate.

Priority between an attorney and other decision-makers for health matters is dealt with elsewhere. Section 36(3) points readers to s 66 of the Guardianship and Administration Act 2000 (Qld).

Withholding or withdrawing a life-sustaining measure

Section 36(2) sets out strict rules for Queensland. All of its conditions must be met before a direction to withhold or withdraw a life-sustaining measure can operate.

First, a clinical situation must apply. This could be a terminal illness expected to cause death within a year (confirmed by two doctors), a persistent vegetative state, permanent unconsciousness, or an illness too severe to recover from without ongoing life-sustaining measures.

Second, if the direction involves artificial nutrition or hydration, stopping or continuing it must fit good medical practice. This extra requirement does not apply to other measures.

Third, the principal must have no reasonable prospect of regaining capacity for health matters. This is a separate requirement. Meeting the first condition does not automatically mean capacity won’t return.

What the Act does not authorise

Section 37 sets a limit. It does not say the Act allows killing a person.

It also does not change s 284 of the Criminal Code (Qld). Under s 284, consenting to your own death does not remove criminal responsibility.

Chapter 28 of the Criminal Code still applies too. This covers speeding up death and helping someone suicide.

So this is a Queensland point about two separate things. Section 36(2) says when a direction to withdraw treatment legally operates. Section 37 confirms that this operation does not excuse conduct beyond what the Act allows.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by checking capacity. For a direction or an attorney’s power over personal or health matters, show the person lacks capacity for that specific matter.

If both a directive and an attorney’s health power exist, apply s 35(3). This gives the directive priority, but only so far as it actually gives directions.

For life-sustaining measures, work through all three parts of s 36(2) separately. Don’t merge them into one step.

If relying on the terminal illness pathway, confirm two doctors share that opinion.

For artificial nutrition or hydration, also deal with the extra requirement of good medical practice.

Keep s 37 and the Criminal Code provisions separate from the question of whether the direction itself operates.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.