Restrictive practices and behaviour support under the NDIS
The Commonwealth regulates the provider, not the practice
Part 2 of the Rules sets conditions of registration for providers who use restrictive practices. Breaching these conditions is a breach of registration, not an unlawful act under the Rules itself. This triggers the Commissioner’s regulatory powers.
If a State or Territory prohibits a restrictive practice, s 8(2) makes this a condition of registration. The provider must not use that practice there. The Commonwealth adopts the State’s prohibition, rather than creating its own.
If a State or Territory has an authorisation process instead, s 9(2) imposes two conditions. First, any use beyond a single emergency use must be authorised under that process. Second, the provider must lodge evidence of authorisation with the Commissioner, as soon as reasonably practicable.
Where a behaviour support plan is in place
Section 10 applies when a provider uses a regulated restrictive practice under a behaviour support plan.
Two conditions apply. The provider must only use the practice as the plan allows. The provider must also tell a specialist behaviour support provider if things change and the plan needs review.
Section 10(3) adds another condition. The provider must agree to show they are complying, if the Commissioner asks them to.
Where there is authorisation but no plan
Section 11 covers a specific situation. A restrictive practice is authorised by the State or Territory, but no behaviour support plan yet covers it.
This applies when authorisation was required and obtained. It also applies when the use did not follow a plan, and the use will likely continue.
In this case, the provider must take all reasonable steps. They must help a specialist behaviour support provider develop an interim plan. This plan must cover the use within one month after it first happened.
This duty starts because the practice is likely to continue. It does not depend on anyone making a complaint.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by identifying the State or Territory where the support was delivered. This comes before anything else.
Next, test the conduct against s 9 of the Act. Then check it against the five categories in s 6 of the Rules. State which category (or “limb”) applies.
Apply the elements of that category. For chemical, mechanical and physical restraint, find the primary purpose of the conduct. Then apply that category’s own carve-out, an exception removing some conduct from the category.
Ask whether the jurisdiction prohibits the practice under s 8, or instead has an authorisation process under s 9. Answer using that jurisdiction’s own law, not a general rule.
Ask whether a behaviour support plan covers the use (s 10) or does not (s 11). If it does not, test every condition in s 11(1) first, before considering the one-month interim plan obligation.
Finally, frame the consequence as a breach of a condition of registration. Do not frame it as making the practice unlawful under the Rules.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.