NDIS plans and reasonable and necessary supports
The principles governing plans
Section 31 sets out principles for preparing, varying, reassessing and replacing a plan, and for managing its funding. These apply “so far as reasonably practicable” — meaning they guide the process, but are not absolute requirements.
A plan should be individualised and directed by the participant. It should respect the role of family and carers, and recognise the participant’s relationships with them. For child participants, it should build the capacity of carers, and may do the same in adult life if the participant and carers agree.
The plan should also consider informal supports and services already available in the community, and help communities respond to participants’ goals. It should be underpinned by the participant’s right to control their own life, and aim to advance inclusion and individual aspirations.
These are principles, not criteria. They shape how planning is carried out, but a support does not have to satisfy them as a test.
The seven criteria
Section 34(1) sets the key test. The CEO must be satisfied of seven things before a support can be included in a participant’s plan.
The support must meet an impairment-related need (aa), fit the participant’s goals (a), help them participate socially and economically (b), offer value for money (c), reflect good practice (d), account for informal support like family and community (e), and count as an NDIS support (f).
Paragraph (aa) is often missed. It requires a link between the support and an impairment that meets the disability or early intervention requirements. Even a clearly beneficial support fails here if it addresses an unrelated need. The CEO tests all requirements at the time they decide to approve the statement.
Paragraph (e) deals with informal supports. This is a strict criterion, not a discretion. It asks what is reasonable to expect from family, carers or community, not merely what is possible for them to do.
Section 34(2) allows rules to set extra methods or matters relevant to these criteria. Those rules must be checked before applying the test.
Applying this in a problem question
First, work out which framework applies, using the rules and any s 32B notice, before looking at plan-content provisions.
Then pin down the exact support in dispute and the specific criterion in issue. Don’t just argue the support is generally useful.
Apply s 34(1)(aa) first. Check the need traces back to an impairment where the participant meets s 24 or s 25 when the statement is approved.
For value for money under s 34(1)(c), compare the cost against alternative supports, not against cost alone.
For s 34(1)(e), focus on what it’s reasonable to expect informal networks to provide, not what they could theoretically provide.
Separate two different complaints: disagreement with what the plan included, versus the Agency’s compliance with an approved statement under s 39.
For an old framework plan, check whether a s 34A determination applies (the plan must start on or after the determination commences) and whether it cuts funding for social, economic and community participation, or improved daily living skills. If total plan funding dropped, check whether the participant is a high support needs participant who made a s 47B request within 90 days. A variation cannot restore funding to those two reduced groups.
Self-check
Before relying on the seven criteria, check that you have treated them as cumulative. This means a support must satisfy all seven, not just some of them.
Check that you have linked the support back to a qualifying impairment. This link is tested at approval, under s 34(1)(aa).
Check whether rules made under s 34(2) prescribe how a particular criterion applies. These rules can affect how you apply the test.
Keep the question of what the plan should contain separate from the question of s 39 compliance. These are two different issues.
Finally, check whether a s 34A determination applies to this plan and this group of supports. Do not assume funding is reduced just because a support meets s 34(1).
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.