Medical treatment decisions in Victoria
The medical treatment decision maker
In Victoria, if there is no applicable instructional directive, a medical treatment decision maker decides instead. Section 61(1) sets the standard: they must make the decision they reasonably believe the person would have made, if that person had decision-making capacity. This is called substituted judgment.
This approach matches South Australia’s guardianship standard, but differs from New South Wales’s welfare and interests test. However, Victoria only uses substituted judgment for medical treatment decisions. Victoria’s own guardianship Act uses a different standard, based on will and preferences. So the three jurisdictions are not consistent across all topics, and each statute must be read on its own terms.
Section 61(2) sets out how the decision maker must form that belief, in a set order.
First, they must consider any valid and relevant values directive. Next, they must consider any other relevant preferences the person expressed, including the circumstances of those preferences.
If no relevant preferences can be found either way, they must then consider the person’s values. These values may come from statements other than a values directive, or be inferred from how the person lived their life.
This means a values directive still matters, even though it is not binding, because it must be considered first. The final step is broader still: it allows inference from a person’s life, not just their express statements.
Applying this in a problem question
First check if the document actually calls the provision an instructional directive. If it does not say so, s 12(3)(a) treats it as a values directive instead, meaning it states the person’s values rather than a fixed instruction.
If an instructional directive is unclear about how it applies to the facts, use s 12(3)(b) to work out its meaning. Do not read the words narrowly or strictly.
For an instructional directive, apply s 60(1). This section covers a consent to treatment, not only a refusal.
Before concluding a practitioner must follow the directive, check s 60 against s 51. Section 60 only applies subject to s 51’s limits.
If no instructional directive applies, the test under s 61(1) is substituted judgment. This means deciding what the person themselves would have chosen, not what is objectively in their best interests.
Then work through the s 61(2) steps in the order given. If nothing express is available, the third step lets you infer the person’s values from how they lived their life.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.