Malicious prosecution
Initiating or maintaining a prosecution
To be liable, a defendant must have actively set the prosecution in motion. Just giving honest information to police is not enough, since the prosecutor decides whether to charge.
But a defendant is liable if they procured the prosecution. This means giving information they knew was false, hiding facts that weakened the case, or pressuring the prosecutor so their independent judgement was displaced.
A defendant can also be liable for maintaining a prosecution. This happens if they continue it after learning facts that remove the reasonable and probable cause it started with.
Absence of reasonable and probable cause
This element defeats most claims. It requires the plaintiff to prove a negative: that there was no reasonable and probable cause. This must be judged at the time the prosecution started, not with hindsight.
There are two parts to the test. Subjectively, did the prosecutor honestly believe the case was proper to bring to court? Objectively, did the prosecutor have enough material for a reasonable person to form that belief?
Both parts must fail before the plaintiff succeeds. So a prosecutor who honestly but unreasonably believed the case was sound may still defeat the claim. The same applies to a prosecutor who had good material but personally doubted it. The plaintiff carries the burden of proving absence of cause, and an acquittal alone is not enough.
The standard is not proof of guilt. The prosecutor only needs to believe the material justifies a trial. This is a much lower bar than proving the accused guilty.
Malice
Malice means the defendant had an improper purpose. The proper purpose is carrying the law into effect.
Spite or ill-will counts as malice. So does any other improper purpose, like pressuring the plaintiff, deflecting blame, or gaining some other advantage.
Malice is a separate element from reasonable and probable cause. Proving the defendant lacked reasonable and probable cause does not by itself prove malice.
But the absence of cause can still help. Combined with other evidence, it may support an inference of malice.
Both elements are independent. A plaintiff must prove each one separately.
Related actions, and how to keep them apart
Malicious prosecution overlaps with other actions. Keep them separate.
False imprisonment deals with the detention itself. It needs no proof of malice or lack of cause. It is the stronger claim when the arrest had no lawful authority.
Abuse of process deals with proceedings that started properly but are used for a collateral purpose (an improper hidden aim). Unlike malicious prosecution, it does not require the case to have ended in the plaintiff’s favour.
Negligent investigation is not a recognised tort in Australia. Pleading it is a common mistake.
Malicious prosecution can extend to some civil proceedings and to steps before trial. These extensions are narrow. Treat them as exceptions, not assumptions.
Damage
You must actually suffer harm to win this tort. It is not actionable per se, meaning you cannot sue just because the prosecution happened. Damage is not always treated as a separate fifth element, but it is still required.
There are three recognised types of damage. Damage to reputation covers charges that would harm your good name. Damage to the person covers loss of liberty, such as arrest or remand.
Damage to property mainly means the cost of defending the prosecution, beyond what you recover in an award. General damages for distress, anxiety and reputational harm are usually the biggest part of any payout.
Exemplary damages can also be awarded, but only where the defendant’s conduct was contumelious (deliberately defiant or shameless). These damages are more readily given when the defendant abused a public office.
Proceedings other than criminal
This tort mainly covers criminal prosecutions. Its reach into civil proceedings is narrow.
Courts have allowed claims for malicious civil actions in limited cases. These include winding up, bankruptcy, and proceedings that harm reputation or property in a similar way. There is no general right to sue someone for maliciously bringing any civil claim.
Why the limit? A costs order (where the loser pays the winner’s legal costs) is usually seen as fair compensation. Courts do not want a separate lawsuit following every failed case.
Other options may work better, like statutory remedies or disciplinary complaints. Separately, the tort of abuse of process can apply. That tort covers cases where proceedings were valid, but used for an improper purpose.
Applying this in a problem question
Work out who actually started or kept pushing the prosecution. Check whether police used their own independent discretion. That independence can break the chain of responsibility back to the defendant.
Check the proceedings ended in the plaintiff’s favour. Explain why that particular type of ending counts as favourable.
Fix the exact time for judging reasonable and probable cause. Then apply the subjective limb and the objective limb separately, not as one test.
Look at malice on its own, separate from absence of reasonable cause. Identify the improper purpose that is actually being alleged.
Also think about false imprisonment and abuse of process as alternatives. On the same facts, these claims are often stronger.
Self-check
Before concluding, check a few things.
Remember that the plaintiff carries the burden. They must prove there was no reasonable and probable cause for the prosecution.
Judge that absence of cause at the time the decision was made. Do not use hindsight to assess it.
Treat malice as its own separate element. Do not simply infer malice from a lack of reasonable cause.
Finally, consider whether the facts better suit false imprisonment or abuse of process instead.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.