Noting up legislation: authorised versions, compilation dates and uncommenced amendments

Authorised versions and what they establish

A compilation becomes an “authorised version” if it is registered, on the approved website, in the right format, and marked as authorised (s 15ZA(1)).

The Act presumes this authorised version correctly shows the law as amended and in force on the compilation date (s 15ZA(5)(h)). This presumption can be disproved, and it does not cover retrospective amendments not yet reflected in the compilation (s 15Q(4)).

Courts and tribunals do not usually need separate proof of a registered law’s text, commencement, or compilation date (s 15ZB(1)(c), (e), (g)). The authorised version is treated as reliable for this purpose, again subject to the s 15Q(4) exception (s 15ZB(3)-(4)).

The “approved website” is whatever the rules prescribe (s 15C). The passage does not say what the rules actually require.

For research, this means you should cite and quote the authorised version itself, not a copy on another site. Always check any other copy against the authorised version.

Remember the presumption only confirms the law as it stood on the compilation date. It does not guarantee the law is still the same now.

Why this matters for noting up a case

A court case applies one version of a provision: the version the court says governed the facts. This version can differ from the law now in force, and from the law when judgment was given.

If the provision has since been amended, repealed or replaced, the case only tells you what the old text meant. It may say nothing reliable about the current text.

A case citator (a tool checking if a case is still good law) won’t necessarily flag this. That’s because the change happened to the legislation, not to later case law.

So when noting up, identify which version the court applied. Read the authorised version in force on the date relevant to your problem, compare the two, and state in your answer which version you rely on.

Applying this in a problem question

This section only covers Commonwealth legislation. First, work out which Act or instrument applies, and confirm it is a Commonwealth one.

Get the authorised version of the latest registered compilation. Note its compilation number, its compilation date, and the date you checked it.

Read the opening notes. These tell you if editorial changes were made, which amending Acts are included, and whether any amendments have not yet commenced.

Check the endnotes’ legislation history too. Look for amending Acts that commence after the compilation date, and for any application, saving or transitional provisions.

Check whether a newer compilation exists since the one you have. If your problem concerns a past date, get the version that was in force then.

If you rely on a case, check which version of the provision the court applied. Compare that version with the one relevant to your own problem.

Finally, state which version you relied on in your answer. If a later amendment has not commenced, say so.

Self-check

Before relying on a compilation, check a few things.

Have you written down the compilation number and date, not just the Act’s name?

Have you remembered that the presumption in s 15ZA(5)(h) only tells you about the compilation date? It does not tell you the law is current today.

Have you checked the endnotes for amendments that commence after that compilation date?

Have you worked out which version of a provision a case actually applied? Then compare that version with the one relevant to your problem.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.