Natural law theory

The core natural law claim

Natural law theory says law and morality are closely connected. An unjust law is deficient as law. Some versions go further and say it is not law at all, even if properly enacted.

This idea is often put as “an unjust law is not a law” (lex injusta non est lex). Natural lawyers disagree about how far this goes. A moderate view says an unjust rule is still valid, but defective. This gives people strong moral reason to change or resist it. A stronger view says an unjust rule is not really law at all.

Natural law theory does not say judges should ignore legal rules and just follow their own morality. It is a claim about what law is. It says law’s authority depends partly on a moral order that exists independently of human lawmaking. Some versions go further, saying moral standards are needed for a rule to be legally valid at all.

Classical natural law: reasoning from a moral order

This tradition follows thinkers like Aquinas. It says law must come from, and answer to, a rational moral order.

Sometimes this moral order is explained in religious terms. Other times it is explained through practical reason aimed at real human goods.

Human-made law, called positive law, applies these broader moral principles to a specific community. A rule that directly contradicts these principles is not valid law. It is a corruption of law instead.

This approach focuses less on how legal systems work day to day. It focuses more on explaining why law has authority at all.

Modern natural law: Fuller’s inner morality of law

Lon Fuller offers a modern natural law theory. It focuses on procedure, not morality’s content.

Fuller says law has an inner morality. This means rules must meet certain procedural standards to count as law at all.

These standards include being general, public, and prospective (applying only to future conduct, not past acts). Rules must also be clear, consistent, possible to follow, stable, and actually enforced as stated.

A system that badly fails these standards risks not being law at all. Examples include secret rules or rules that change after the fact.

Students find this approach appealing. It avoids contested moral claims, yet still challenges positivism by insisting law has some built-in evaluative content.

Why this is the standard foil to positivism

Natural law theory is taught next to positivism because they argue about the same question. That question is how law relates to morality. One issue is whether an unjust law stops being valid, loses moral authority, or simply fails to be law in the fullest sense.

Positivism says a valid rule is still law, no matter its moral content. Natural law, in its various versions, rejects this. It denies that validity and moral merit can be fully separated.

Neither theory is simply correct. The debate exists because lawyers really do speak both ways. We say “that’s the law, however unjust” (a positivist statement). We also say “that’s not really law, that’s tyranny dressed up as law” (a natural law statement).

Studying both theories helps you recognise which kind of statement an argument is making.

Applying this in a problem question

First, work out what kind of criticism you are making. A natural law argument says the rule fails as law. A policy argument says the rule is bad and should be reformed. These lead to different conclusions, so keep them separate.

If you rely on Fuller’s inner morality of law, test the rule against specific failures. Look for secrecy, retroactivity, unintelligibility, or promises that are never administered. Do not rely on a vague sense of unfairness.

Natural law reasoning can support an argument that a supposed exercise of legal power should not count as valid. This works best where the defect concerns basic legality, not just policy preference.

Always say which version of natural law you are using. The moderate version says the rule is valid but defective. The strong version says it is not law at all. The strength of your conclusion depends on which one you choose.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.