Intoxication

The common law position

In R v O’Connor (1980) the High Court set the common law rule on intoxication. It held the prosecution must prove the fault element (the required mental state) actually existed. Evidence that the accused was too intoxicated to form that fault element is admissible, whatever the offence charged.

This differs from the English approach, which only allowed intoxication evidence for offences of specific intent (crimes requiring a particular further purpose).

This common law position is now mostly of historical interest. Almost every Australian jurisdiction has legislated to change it.

In New South Wales, the common law position is abolished by statute. Section 428H of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) states that the common law on intoxication is abolished, for offences committed after Part 11A commenced (s 428I).

Part 11A sets out the new rules. Evidence of intoxication can be considered for offences of specific intent (s 428C). For other offences, self-induced intoxication cannot be considered on the mental element, but non-self-induced intoxication can (s 428D). Self-induced intoxication also cannot be considered on whether the accused’s conduct was voluntary (s 428G(1)).

In Harkins v R [2015], the court confirmed that s 428H blocks reliance on the O’Connor common law principle in New South Wales. This is only the New South Wales position; other jurisdictions have their own separate laws, not covered here.

The Code jurisdictions

Code jurisdictions have their own rules on intoxication. They don’t use the common law categories.

Instead, intoxication generally matters when the crime needs an intention to cause a specific result. Otherwise, it’s usually disregarded.

This is a different structure, but it often reaches similar outcomes to the common law. Don’t use “specific intent” or “basic intent” language in a Code answer unless you check the Code actually uses those terms.

Intoxication and the defences

Intoxication can affect defences that depend on what the accused believed or perceived.

Self-defence needs a belief that the conduct was necessary, and a reasonable response in the circumstances as the accused saw them. The belief part is subjective, so intoxication may matter here. But most statutes say the reasonableness of the response is judged by a sober person, or they rule out intoxicated mistakes entirely.

Duress and necessity work the same way. They also involve a belief about a threat, and the same statutory limits usually apply.

Mistake of fact cannot rest on a mistake caused by self-induced intoxication, where this defence applies.

Overall, statutes tend to follow one pattern. A subjective belief may take intoxication into account. But any reasonableness requirement is still judged by the standard of a sober person.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by noting that intoxication affects proof of the fault element. It is not an excuse on its own.

Next, work out which jurisdiction applies. Find the provision that governs before you use any distinction.

Where that jurisdiction draws the line, classify the offence as specific intent or basic intent. Explain why you classified it that way.

Check whether the intoxication was self-induced. This decides whether any restrictions apply at all.

Finally, deal with voluntariness and mistaken belief as separate issues. The statutes treat them separately, so keep them apart.

Where the argument actually gets made

Intoxication rarely leads to a full acquittal. Instead, it usually matters for two narrower questions.

The first question is whether the accused actually formed the specific intent needed for the offence. The second is whether the accused should be convicted of a lesser alternative offence instead.

A common example is murder being reduced to manslaughter. Another is wounding with intent being reduced to a lesser wounding charge.

This is a more accurate way to understand intoxication than treating it as a path to acquittal. It also reflects how the argument is actually run at trial.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.