Treaty incorporation into Australian law
Treaty-making is an exercise of executive power
Making treaties for Australia uses the Commonwealth’s executive power. This is the government’s power to act, separate from Parliament’s power to make laws.
Parliament does not need to pass an Act for Australia to sign or ratify a treaty. Ratifying means formally agreeing to be bound by the treaty under international law.
Parliament’s approval is not legally required before Australia becomes bound internationally.
In practice, treaties are usually tabled in Parliament and reviewed before ratification. But this is a political and administrative safeguard, not a legal requirement.
The power to bind Australia to a treaty stays with the executive, regardless of this practice.
Dualism: no automatic domestic effect
Australia uses a dualist approach. This means international law and domestic law are treated as separate systems.
In Chow Hung Ching v The King (1948), a case about visiting forces’ immunity, the judges discussed this. Latham CJ said international law is not automatically part of Australian law. Dixon J said a treaty (other than one ending a war) does not by itself change the rights and duties of people in Australia.
So when Australia signs a treaty, it becomes bound internationally. Australia may face international consequences for breaking the treaty. But the treaty gives no enforceable rights in Australian courts, unless Parliament passes legislation to implement it.
This requirement is called incorporation. Incorporation means Parliament makes a law giving the treaty legal force domestically. Until Parliament does this, courts treat the treaty as an international matter, not a source of domestic rights or duties.
Implementing a treaty also raises a constitutional issue. The Commonwealth Parliament can only legislate using powers listed in the Constitution. So the question becomes: does the Constitution actually give Parliament power to legislate on that topic?
The external affairs power (s 51(xxix)) is the power most often used to support treaty-implementing legislation. Whether specific legislation is validly supported by this power is a separate, more complex constitutional question, not covered here.
Indirect influence without incorporation
An unincorporated treaty is one Parliament has not turned into domestic law. Even so, it can still shape Australian law in indirect ways.
Courts presume Parliament does not mean to legislate against Australia’s international obligations. So if a law is genuinely ambiguous, courts will generally favour a reading that fits a relevant treaty, even an unincorporated one.
An unincorporated treaty may also count in administrative decision-making. A decision-maker may be bound, or at least entitled, to consider it. Courts have sometimes said ratifying a treaty creates a legitimate expectation (a reasonable assumption a decision-maker will act in line with it) that decision-makers will follow it, though this idea has been debated and narrowed over time.
Finally, courts sometimes use international instruments, including unincorporated treaties, to help clarify unclear areas of the common law.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by checking whether the treaty has been incorporated into Australian law by legislation, or whether it remains unincorporated.
If it is unincorporated, say clearly that it gives no directly enforceable domestic rights or duties. Entering the treaty was an exercise of executive power, not legislative power.
Then work through the indirect avenues one by one. Ask whether the problem involves ambiguous legislation needing interpretation, a discretionary decision raising relevant considerations or legitimate expectation, or an undeveloped area of common law.
Where implementing legislation exists, base your answer on that statute, not on the treaty’s own text.
Finally, do not assume that ratification alone gives a treaty the same legal status as an Act of Parliament. Confusing the two is the most common mistake on this topic.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.