Sources of international law
Treaties
A treaty is a written agreement between states. It is meant to create binding obligations under international law. Treaties can be bilateral (two states) or multilateral (many states).
A state that joins a treaty is bound by it under international law. This rests on the idea that agreements must be honoured.
Treaties are the closest thing international law has to legislation. But they only bind states that have agreed to join them.
Importantly, a treaty binding a state internationally does not automatically become part of that state’s domestic law. Later articles in this module explain this point further.
Customary international law
Customary international law (CIL) is not based on agreement. It comes from actual practice by states.
A rule becomes custom only when two things exist together. First, state practice: conduct that is general, consistent, and widespread among states.
Second, opinio juris: states must believe they are legally obliged to act that way. This belief is what turns mere habit into binding law.
A widespread practice followed only out of courtesy or convenience does not count. Even if every state does it, without that sense of legal obligation, it stays a habit, not custom.
Because custom depends on real practice, it can change as state conduct and belief change. It can also bind states that never agreed to it.
There is one limited exception. A state that persistently and openly objected to a rule while it was forming may not be bound by it.
General principles of law
Sometimes treaties and custom don’t cover a situation. Here, tribunals can use general principles of law instead.
These are ideas shared by legal systems around the world. Examples include good faith, estoppel, and the rule that no one should profit from their own wrong.
This source fills gaps. It only applies when more specific sources, like treaties or custom, stay silent on the issue.
Subsidiary means: judicial decisions and scholarly writing
Court decisions and scholarly writings are not sources of international law like treaties, custom or general principles. They do not create legal obligations themselves.
Instead, they are called subsidiary means. This means they help identify what the law already is, rather than making new law.
A court decision can be very persuasive. A widely cited scholarly view can also shape how states and tribunals understand a rule.
Even so, both remain secondary. They help interpret the primary sources, but do not replace them.
How the sources relate
These sources don’t have a strict hierarchy. But a treaty can’t override a peremptory norm — a rule so fundamental it binds all states.
In practice, lawyers follow a set order. They check treaties first, then custom, then general principles.
Judicial decisions and scholarly writing support this process throughout. They provide evidence of what each source actually requires.
Applying this in a problem question
Work through these steps in order.
First, check for a treaty. See if the relevant states are parties, and read what it says.
If no treaty applies, ask whether customary international law applies instead. Test this against both state practice and opinio juris (the belief that a practice is legally required), not practice alone.
If treaty and custom both fail to resolve the issue, consider general principles of law shared by legal systems.
Judicial decisions and scholarly writing can help you work out what a source contains. They are not sources of law themselves.
Finally, keep international law separate from Australian domestic law. Whether Australia’s own law requires anything is a different question, covered elsewhere.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.