Recognition of foreign judgments

Recognition is not automatic

A foreign court’s judgment is not automatically part of Australian law. An Australian court does not have to follow it just because a competent foreign court made it.

Instead, recognition must be actively established. The party relying on the foreign judgment generally must prove it deserves recognition.

This fits a system of separate legal orders: each country’s courts get their power from their own legal system. So courts in one country don’t automatically defer to another country’s courts just because a judgment exists.

Recognition and enforcement are related but distinct

Recognition and enforcement sound similar, but they are different things.

Recognition means treating a foreign judgment as final on the matters it decided. This can stop the same issue being argued again in Australia.

Enforcement goes further. It means an Australian court uses its power to make the judgment work here, such as letting a creditor collect money the foreign court ordered paid.

A judgment can be recognised without being enforced. But someone wanting to enforce a foreign money judgment will usually need to show recognition first.

Grounds on which recognition can be refused

Recognition of a foreign judgment is not automatic. Australian courts can refuse recognition on certain grounds, even if the judgment looks regular. These grounds let a court check the judgment, not re-decide the original dispute.

One ground is lack of proper jurisdiction. If the foreign court lacked jurisdiction over the defendant or the dispute, judged by Australian standards, its judgment won’t be recognised.

Another is breach of natural justice. This means a party was denied a fair hearing, such as proper notice or a chance to put their case.

Fraud is also a ground. A judgment obtained by fraud, whether fraud on the court or fraud about jurisdiction, won’t be recognised.

Public policy is another ground. Courts can refuse recognition if enforcing the judgment would breach fundamental Australian public policy.

Finally, the judgment must be final and conclusive in its home court. Importantly, a pending appeal does not stop it being final: s 5(5) of the Foreign Judgments Act 1991 (Cth) says a judgment is still final even if an appeal is possible or pending. An appeal only affects enforcement, not recognition — s 8 allows courts to pause enforcement until the appeal is decided. Finality asks whether the original court is done with the case, not whether it could still be appealed.

Pathways to recognition

There is more than one way to get a foreign judgment recognised in Australia. Which pathway applies depends on the country’s court and the type of judgment.

Some judgments get a statutory shortcut. Under the Foreign Judgments Act 1991 (Cth), a judgment creditor (the party owed money) can apply to register a judgment within six years, but only if the judgment is from a court the regulations designate.

If no such scheme applies, the creditor may instead rely on general principles. This includes treating the foreign judgment as creating a fresh cause of action in an Australian court.

The grounds for refusal already discussed still apply, whichever pathway is used. A student should spot that a pathway exists and reason about those grounds, rather than guessing at a scheme’s precise mechanics.

Applying this in a problem question

First, check the judgment came from a foreign court, not an Australian one.

Next, work out if the question is about recognition, enforcement, or both. Recognition means accepting the judgment as valid; enforcement means making it operate here. Explain the difference if it matters.

Remember recognition is not automatic. Say who must prove the judgment should be recognised.

Then go through the possible grounds for refusal: jurisdiction, natural justice, fraud, public policy, and finality. Only discuss the ones the facts actually raise.

Finally, do not treat this as an appeal. An Australian court recognising a foreign judgment does not re-decide the original dispute.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.