Choice of law and jurisdiction
Two distinct questions
There are two separate questions. Jurisdiction asks whether a court has the power to hear and decide a dispute at all.
Choice of law asks something different. Once a court has jurisdiction, which legal system’s law should it use to decide the case? A court can have jurisdiction but still apply another system’s law, not its own.
These questions come in order. A court must find jurisdiction first. Having jurisdiction says nothing about which law will apply.
Jurisdiction
A court’s jurisdiction means its legal power to hear a case. This power usually depends on some link between the dispute, the parties, and the court.
For example, a court may have jurisdiction if the defendant can be served within that jurisdiction. It may also arise if the defendant submits to the court — meaning they accept its authority by taking part in the case. Other recognised connections between the dispute and the forum can also found jurisdiction.
Sometimes more than one court could claim jurisdiction over a dispute. When this happens, a separate question can arise: is this particular court a suitable or appropriate one to hear the case? This is different from asking whether the court technically has the power to hear it.
Choice of law
After a court decides it has jurisdiction, it uses its own choice-of-law rules to pick which system’s law applies. These rules belong to the forum itself. Different disputes use different connecting factors.
Contract disputes often look at the law the parties intended, or the law most closely connected to the agreement. Disputes about wrongs to a person or property often look to the law of the place where the wrong happened. This rule was confirmed for Australian tort claims, including interstate ones, in John Pfeiffer Pty Ltd v Rogerson.
There is also a distinction between substance and procedure. A court always applies its own procedural law, called the lex fori, no matter which law governs the substance of the case.
Choice-of-law rules only apply to substantive questions. Procedural matters, like how evidence is presented, are always governed by the forum’s own law.
Domestic as well as international
Australia’s states and territories each have their own laws. So conflict-of-laws questions — about jurisdiction and choice of law — can arise within Australia itself, not just internationally. An example is an accident in one state but a case brought in another state’s courts.
Australian courts use the same basic conflict-of-laws reasoning for these interstate disputes as for international ones. They adapt it to the federal context, including cooperative arrangements that reduce friction between state courts.
Defamation is different. Section 11 of the Defamation Act 2005 (SA) sets its own rule. Under s 11(1), if matter is published wholly in one Australian jurisdictional area, the substantive law of that area applies.
Section 11(2) changes this for “multiple publication” across more than one Australian area. Here, courts apply the law of the area with the “closest connection” to the harm from the publication as a whole. This picks one law for the whole publication, not separate laws for each place of publication. Other states’ uniform Defamation Acts contain substantially the same rule.
The case of Pfeiffer established the choice-of-law rule for torts within Australia (intranational torts). It deliberately left international cases aside.
Regie Nationale des Usines Renault SA v Zhang later extended this rule to foreign torts. The majority (Gleeson CJ, Gaudron, McHugh, Gummow and Hayne JJ) held the rule applies to foreign torts too, even without the “federal considerations” present in Pfeiffer. They rejected any “flexible exception” to the rule.
Kirby J agreed the rule extends to international torts. However, he would have left open whether a “flexible exception” might apply, though he did not dissent over this. Callinan J, who dissented on other grounds, said nothing about extending Pfeiffer to foreign torts.
So cite Pfeiffer for torts within Australia, and Zhang for foreign torts.
Neilson v Overseas Projects Corporation of Victoria Ltd then considered what “lex loci delicti” actually refers to — the law of the place where the tort occurred.
Applying this in a problem question
First, check the dispute genuinely connects to more than one legal system. Identify each system involved, and why.
Ask the jurisdiction question first — can this court actually hear the case? Only then ask the choice-of-law question: which system’s law governs each issue?
Don’t assume the court automatically uses its own law. Instead, identify the connecting factor pointing to the applicable law.
Keep substantive issues (covered by choice of law) separate from procedural issues, which are always governed by the forum’s law.
Finally, note whether the conflict is international or interstate. The specific rules may differ, even though the underlying questions stay the same.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.