Trade marks
What a trade mark protects
A trade mark is a sign (s 17). This can be a word, phrase, logo, shape, or even a colour, sound or scent. It must be used, or meant to be used, to tell one trader’s goods or services apart from another’s.
Its job is to act as a badge of origin. It shows consumers which trader is behind a product, protecting the trader’s reputation in that sign.
This differs from copyright, which protects expressive content, and patents, which protect inventions. A trade mark only protects the sign as a marker of origin.
Unlike copyright or patents, trade mark registration can in principle be renewed indefinitely, as long as the mark stays in use and renewal fees are paid.
Passing off: protecting unregistered reputation
Passing off is a common law action. It exists separately from the statutory trade mark system, and still applies today.
It protects traders whose reputation and goodwill are harmed by someone else’s conduct. This applies even if the trader has no registered trade mark.
To succeed, a claimant must prove three things. First, goodwill or reputation attached to their goods or services, usually shown through a distinctive name, get-up or mark. Second, a misrepresentation by the defendant, whether deliberate or not, that misleads or is likely to mislead the public into thinking the defendant’s goods are the claimant’s, or connected to them. Third, damage, or a real likelihood of damage, caused by that misrepresentation.
Often a statutory misleading-conduct prohibition applies alongside passing off. This statutory test asks a different question.
Because misleading conduct targets a class of people rather than specific individuals, courts imagine a representative member of that class. The court asks why this hypothetical person’s misconception arose or is likely to arise (Campomar Sociedad, Limitada v Nike International Ltd (2000) 202 CLR 45).
Extreme or fanciful reactions are not attributed to this hypothetical consumer. This is true even if a real witness genuinely held that reaction.
Why both exist
Passing off protects a trader’s actual reputation in the market. It applies even without a registered trade mark.
This matters in three situations. The business may not have registered its mark. The sign might not be distinctive enough to register. Or the needed protection covers goods or services outside the registration.
Registration offers different benefits. It gives clearer, more certain statutory rights. The trader does not need to reprove reputation and confusion each time.
Most well-advised traders register their mark. But they also keep passing off in reserve, for gaps registration leaves uncovered.
Applying this in a problem question
First, check if the sign is registered. If it is, start with the Trade Marks Act and its infringement test.
If the sign is unregistered, or registration is doubtful, use passing off instead. This means checking goodwill, misrepresentation, and damage.
For registration problems, test distinctiveness. Ask if the sign is inherently adapted to distinguish, or if it needs evidence of acquired distinctiveness through use.
For infringement problems, compare the marks and the goods or services involved. Ask whether the use is likely to deceive or confuse.
Finally, consider whether both claims are available on the facts. Work out what each claim offers that the other does not.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.