Patents
What a patent protects
A patent protects an invention. This means a defined product or process, not just one way of describing it.
Once granted, the patent owner gets exclusive rights. They can make, use, sell, import or exploit the invention in Australia for the patent’s life, and let others do so too.
This exclusivity is limited to Australia and lasts only while the patent runs.
Because a patent can protect the technical idea itself, once it is defined and new, the requirements for getting one are stricter than for copyright.
The gateway: patentability requirements
To get a patent, an invention must meet three requirements.
First, novelty. This means the invention must not already be public, anywhere, before the priority date (the key cut-off date). Even the applicant’s own earlier publication or public use can destroy novelty.
Second, an inventive step. The invention must not be obvious to a skilled person in the field, given the prior art. If any competent practitioner would have reached it anyway, it fails this test.
Third, manner of manufacture. The invention must create an artificial, economically useful result, not just an abstract idea, a natural law, or bare information. This boundary is still debated, especially for computer-implemented inventions and business methods.
D’Arcy v Myriad Genetics Inc shows this requirement has real limits. The court held an isolated naturally occurring gene sequence was not patentable, since it was not an artificial creation.
Examination and registration
Before granting a patent, the patent office checks the application meets the requirements. This is a substantive, adversarial-in-effect process -- meaning it involves real scrutiny and challenge, unlike copyright, which has no such check.
A standard patent lasts for a limited term, generally up to twenty years. Narrow extensions are available in limited circumstances, such as for certain pharmaceutical patents.
Once the term ends, the invention enters the public domain. Anyone may then use it freely.
The trade-off: disclosure for monopoly
Patent law involves a trade-off. The inventor must disclose enough detail, in the patent specification (the document describing the invention), for a skilled person to understand and later reproduce it.
In return, the inventor gets a temporary but exclusive right to exploit the invention. The disclosure itself benefits the public straight away, even though only the patent owner can use the invention until the patent expires.
An inventor can choose secrecy instead. This means no patent monopoly at all, but the law of confidential information may still protect the invention, for as long as it stays secret.
Contrast with copyright
Copyright and patents work very differently.
Copyright protects a wide range of expressive works. It applies automatically, with no examination, and lasts a long time. But it never protects the idea behind the work, only its expression.
Patents are narrower. They protect new, inventive, useful technical subject matter. A patent only arises after examination and registration, and lasts for a much shorter term. Unlike copyright, a patent can protect the idea itself, if properly claimed.
This means one piece of work, like software, can attract copyright for its written code. That same software might get no patent protection at all, unless its technical solution separately meets the requirements for patentability.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by working out exactly what is claimed as the invention. It might be a product, a process, or both. You must know this before testing anything else.
Next, check novelty. This asks whether the substance of the invention was already made public anywhere before the priority date (the relevant cut-off date).
Then check inventive step. This asks whether the invention would have been obvious to a person skilled in that field, given the prior art (existing knowledge in the area).
Also check manner of manufacture. This asks whether the invention gives an artificially created, useful result. An abstract idea, a mere discovery, or other excluded subject matter will not qualify.
Finally, if any requirement seems doubtful, think about other protections. Confidentiality, copyright or trade mark protection may serve the client better, at least for now, rather than assuming a patent is the only option.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.