Patent infringement: exploitation, supply, exhaustion and exemptions

The exclusive rights: exploiting the invention

A patent gives the patentee exclusive rights to “exploit” the invention, or let someone else exploit it, during the patent’s term (s 13(1)). This right applies across the whole patent area (s 13(3)).

“Exploit” is defined in Schedule 1. For a product, it covers making, hiring, selling, disposing of, offering to do those things, using, importing, or keeping it for those purposes. For a method or process, it covers using the process, or doing those same acts with a product made by that process.

Anyone who does one of these acts without the patentee’s permission infringes the patent.

For process patents, s 121A can shift the burden of proof. This applies where a defendant claims it used a different process to make an identical product. If the court finds it very likely the patented process was actually used, and the patentee tried reasonably but could not discover the real process, the product is presumed made by the patented process. The defendant can still prove otherwise.

After the first sale: exhaustion, repair and making

In Calidad Pty Ltd v Seiko Epson Corporation [2020] HCA 41, a third party modified used Epson printer cartridges so they could be refilled. Calidad then imported and sold these modified cartridges.

The majority (Kiefel CJ, Bell and Keane JJ, with Gageler J agreeing) held that a patentee’s rights over a product are “exhausted” once it is sold without conditions on its use. Exhaustion means the patentee can no longer control what the buyer does with that item. This replaced an older approach based on an “implied licence” from the patentee.

Exhaustion does not stop a patentee setting conditions on future use. But those conditions must be agreed by contract, and enforced through contract law or equity, not patent law.

Exhaustion also does not cover the patentee’s separate right to stop others “making” the invention. So the Court still had to ask whether modifying the cartridges amounted to making a new product.

The majority said it did not. The cartridges remained the original product, just altered to allow reuse. The modifications did not copy the features of the patented invention, and extending a product’s life this way is within an owner’s rights. Whether other kinds of modification count as “making” will still depend on the facts of each case.

Nettle, Gordon and Edelman JJ dissented in part. They would have decided the case only on the “making” question, and found that some categories of modified cartridge did amount to making the patented invention.

Exemptions from infringement

The Act sets out exemptions from patent infringement. Three main ones matter for students.

Prior use (s 119) protects someone already exploiting an invention, or definitely preparing to, before the priority date. This applies only to patents from applications filed after the 2006 change to s 119; older patents use the earlier version. The exemption is lost if the person had stopped or abandoned this use before the priority date, unless the stop was temporary. It also does not cover use copied from the patentee, unless that information was already made public with the patentee’s consent.

Regulatory approval (s 119A) allows exploiting a pharmaceutical invention solely to get therapeutic goods approved in Australia or overseas. Medical devices are excluded. Exporting goods for foreign approval is only covered if the patent term was extended and the conditions in s 119A(2) are met.

Experimental use (s 119C) allows acts done for experimental purposes connected to the invention. This includes testing the invention’s properties, checking a claim’s scope, improving or modifying it, testing its validity, and testing whether it would be infringed.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by identifying whether the claimed invention is a product or a method. List what the defendant actually did, then compare this to the acts covered by “exploit”.

If the defendant dealt with a product the patentee had already sold, apply the exhaustion doctrine from Calidad. Then ask whether the defendant’s work made a new product, rather than merely repairing or modifying the old one.

If the defendant only supplied a product, work through s 117(2)(a), (b) and (c) in turn. Consider the product’s possible uses, what the supplier had reason to believe, and any instructions or advertising given.

Check whether any exemption applies to the facts, particularly prior use before the priority date and experimental purposes.

Finally, consider a counter-claim for revocation under a s 138(3) ground. Then select the relief available under ss 122 and 123, confirming the claim was brought within the s 120(4) time limit.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.