Emerging technology regulation

Why this topic is different from the rest of the module

Copyright, patents, trade marks and confidential information rest on long-settled doctrine. It has been tested and refined over time.

Emerging technology regulation is different. It is not a new, settled area of law. It is an emerging attempt to apply those same old frameworks to new situations they were not built for.

So a student must tell the difference between two things. One is citing settled authority for a proposition. The other is describing law that is still unsettled.

When the law is still being worked out, say so clearly. Do not present an unsettled position as if it were certain.

Copyright and data-driven technologies

AI systems raise copyright questions that current law does not clearly answer. One question is whether using copyright material to train a system counts as “reproduction” under s 31 of the Copyright Act — one of the exclusive rights copyright owners hold. Even if it does, it is unclear whether any existing exception applies.

Another question is whether output from such a system can be an “original work” at all. Australian copyright law has traditionally assumed a work needs a human author. If AI output can be a work, it is unclear who would own it: the system’s builder, its operator, or no one.

A further question is whether fair dealing exceptions (covering purposes like research, review and news reporting) were ever meant to cover large-scale automated use like this.

None of these questions has a settled answer yet. Courts, regulators and law reform bodies are still working through them. A careful student should treat them as open questions, not as settled law.

Privacy and data-driven technology

Privacy law is separate from intellectual property law, but related. It raises its own questions about data-driven technology.

Building these systems often means collecting large amounts of personal information. This raises issues of consent, purpose limitation, and accountability. Purpose limitation means data can only be used for the reason it was collected.

These privacy issues are conceptually distinct from copyright, which protects expression. But the two areas often overlap in practice.

For example, one dataset might raise two separate questions. A copyright question about the material itself, and a privacy question about the personal information inside it.

Confidential information and data

New technologies are also testing the law of confidential information. This law protects information that has the necessary quality of confidence, meaning it is not public and was shared in circumstances implying secrecy.

Some systems are trained on proprietary (privately owned) datasets. This raises a question: does information fed into the system, or later extracted from it, still count as confidential?

A related question is whether unauthorised use of confidential information, to build or run such a system, could itself be a breach of confidence. The passage does not say whether courts have answered this yet.

How a student should approach this area

Do not just memorise today’s rules. Build a method instead.

First, work out which existing legal framework applies. This could be copyright, confidential information, or privacy law.

Second, pinpoint exactly which part of that framework is genuinely unclear when applied to the new technology.

Third, separate real legal questions from policy questions. Policy questions belong to Parliament or a regulator, not a court.

Finally, stay alert to new legislation and case law. Do not treat anything here as a final, fixed answer.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by working out which doctrine applies. New technology problems usually engage copyright, confidential information, or privacy. Sometimes more than one doctrine applies at once.

Next, set out the settled elements of that doctrine. Use the matching sibling article for this, not guesswork.

Then find the specific element that is unclear for this new technology. Do not say the whole area is uncertain when only one part is doubtful.

Also check whether the question is really a legal question at all. Some issues are policy questions for Parliament or a regulator, not open legal questions.

Finally, be honest about any uncertainty in your answer. Do not state a settled conclusion if the current law does not support one.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.