Automated systems and AI in Australian law: what has been enacted and decided
An AI system cannot be named as the inventor
Under the Patents Act 1990 (Cth) s 15(1), a patent can only be granted to the inventor, or to someone who derives rights from the inventor. Dr Stephen Thaler named an AI system, “DABUS”, as the inventor on his application. The Deputy Commissioner treated the application as lapsed, since it named no natural person. A single Federal Court judge set that decision aside.
A Full Federal Court of five judges then reversed this, in Commissioner of Patents v Thaler [2022] FCAFC 62. They held that s 15(1)(a)’s “person who is an inventor” means a natural person, since the other paragraphs derive entitlement from that inventor. Naming DABUS therefore did not satisfy the Patents Regulations.
The Court was careful not to decide too much. It did not rule out all AI-devised inventions being patentable, and did not decide whether this application actually had a human inventor. It said these wider policy questions need urgent consideration.
The High Court later refused special leave to appeal, saying the case wasn’t the right vehicle for those questions of principle. The Full Court’s decision stands, but the High Court has not itself decided the issue.
Sharing sexual deepfakes is a Commonwealth offence
Since 3 September 2024, s 474.17A of the Criminal Code (Cth) criminalises sending sexual images of a person (who is or appears to be an adult) using a carriage service, like the internet or phone network. This covers real or apparently real depictions of sexual activity, sexual organs, the anal region, or a female person’s breasts. The sender must know the person does not consent, or be reckless about it. Recklessness here includes simply not thinking about whether they consented.
It does not matter if the image is real or has been created or altered using technology. The law specifically mentions deepfakes as an example. “Transmit” is broad: it includes making the material available, publishing it, or distributing it.
The maximum penalty is 6 years’ imprisonment.
There are exceptions. The offence does not apply if the transmission helps enforce or investigate a law, is for court or tribunal proceedings, serves a genuine medical or scientific purpose, or is something a reasonable person would see as acceptable in the circumstances. The accused carries an evidential burden to raise these exceptions under s 474.17A(3).
A more serious, aggravated version of the offence applies under s 474.17AA(5). This carries a maximum of 7 years, where the sender also created or altered the material themselves.
Applying this in a problem question
First, pinpoint the exact legal question. Is it about inventorship, whether a decision was actually made, a privacy-policy duty, or a criminal transmission offence?
Next, check whether an enacted law or decided case already answers it. Note when that law started applying, and which court decided the case.
Then apply the answer like ordinary law. For example, name a human as the inventor, ask whether a decision-maker truly reached a conclusion, test the three conditions in APP 1.7, or work through the elements and exceptions in s 474.17A.
Keep a court’s binding holding separate from a dissent (a judge’s disagreeing opinion) or an unresolved question — like whether an AI-assisted invention has a human inventor.
Finally, state clearly which parts of the problem remain unanswered by existing law.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.