Income support for carers and people with disability

Disability support pension: four cumulative limbs

Section 94(1) sets four core requirements that must all be met together. Paragraphs (e) and (ea), covering residence, apply too but are not explained here.

Paragraph (a) requires an impairment, physical, intellectual or psychiatric. This is a broad category. It does not settle the medical question alone: a rating under the Impairment Tables also needs diagnosis by a qualified practitioner, reasonable treatment, stability, and a likelihood the condition will persist.

Paragraph (b) requires that impairment score 20 points or more under the Impairment Tables. The Tables are a separate instrument, not part of the Act. They rate function, not diagnosis. Meeting paragraph (a) does not mean paragraph (b) is met.

Paragraph (c) requires either a continuing inability to work, or Secretary satisfaction that the person is in the supported wage system. These are alternatives. Supported wage system participation is not proof of inability to work.

Paragraph (d) requires the person to have turned 16.

Paragraph (da) adds a participation requirement in defined cases, broadly people under 35 or reviewed 2008–2011 DSP starters. The Secretary must be satisfied the person can work at least 8 hours a week at or above the relevant minimum wage existing in Australia, even if such work is not available locally. Where there are dependent children, the youngest must be 6 or over.

That “exists in Australia” phrase matters. The test is national availability, not local availability. A claimant cannot succeed just by showing no such work exists where they live.

The key structural point: the medical question and the legal question differ. Impairment is only a threshold. The real tests are the Impairment Table points and work capacity, not how severe the condition seems.

Carer payment: constant care, assessed by tool

Section 198(1) sets out the carer payment requirements. All must be met together.

Section 198(2) requires the carer to personally provide constant care. If they are the only carer, the care receiver must be a disabled adult, assessed under the Adult Disability Assessment Tool with a score of at least 25, and a professional questionnaire score of at least 10. Section 197(1) says care includes attention and supervision. A disabled adult is someone aged 16 or over with a permanent, or long-term, physical, intellectual or psychiatric disability. The ADAT score decides the matter, not the diagnosis itself.

Section 198(3) requires the care to happen in the care receiver’s own private residence. This is narrow. Care given in approved residential aged care does not count.

Section 198(4) requires the carer to be an Australian resident. There is a narrow exception for certain international social security agreements made on or before 24 December 1992.

Section 198(5) also tests the care receiver’s own circumstances. They must be an Australian resident, pass the income test under s 198A, and either pass the assets test under s 198D or fall under a s 198N decision. Subsections (6) and (7) remove these requirements for some higher-scoring ADAT adults, mainly those already getting a pension or benefit.

Students often miss this: carer payment is means tested on the care receiver, not just the carer. A carer with little money can still be refused if the care receiver has assets.

Two extra rules matter. Sections 198AA to 198AC let qualification continue through short-term gaps, such as respite or hospital stays. Section 198(9) also deems a supervisor to be personally providing care, where a disabled adult cares for their own dependent child and someone else oversees that care.

Carer allowance: a different payment, a different test

Carer allowance is not a lesser version of carer payment. It is a separate supplementary payment with its own qualification rules.

For a child, s 953(1) applies if the care receiver is a dependent child of the carer, is an Australian resident, and needs daily care and attention because of their disability. That care can come from the carer, the carer’s partner, or the carer with another person, and must happen in a private home shared by both. The disability must also be a recognised disability under s 38E(3), or rated “intense” under the Disability Care Load Assessment (Child) Determination. The carer must be an Australian resident meeting the carer allowance income test.

For an adult, s 954(1) applies if the care receiver is an Australian resident, and is a family member of the carer or someone approved in writing by the Secretary. The care receiver must score at least 30 under the Adult Disability Assessment Tool, including at least 12 on the professional questionnaire. Daily care and attention must be given because of the disability, by the carer alone or with another person, in a home shared by both. The carer must also be an Australian resident meeting the income test. Section 954A offers a separate pathway when the adult and carer do not live together.

The key exam comparison is between the two payments. Carer payment demands “constant care,” a higher standard than carer allowance’s “daily” care and attention.

Scoring thresholds also differ. Under carer payment, a sole carer of a disabled adult (s 198(2)(a)(i)) needs an ADAT score of at least 25, while carer allowance for an adult needs at least 30. So the supplementary payment actually has a higher threshold here — a point worth remembering. Other carer payment routes use different scores: at least 80 where more than one carer shares constant care (s 198(2)(a)(ii)), and at least 20 where the care receivers are a disabled adult and a dependent child under 16 (s 198(2)(d)).

Living arrangements differ too. Section 954 requires the adult to be cared for in a home shared by both the adult and the carer. Section 198(3), by contrast, only requires the home to belong to the care receiver.

Applying this in a problem question

First, work out whose payment is in question. Is it the person with disability, or the carer? This decides which provisions you use.

For disability support pension, go through s 94(1) in order. Check impairment points under paragraph (b) and the work or supported-wage test in paragraph (c) separately. Then check age under paragraph (d). Only look at the participation requirement in paragraph (da) if the age or starter criteria are met. Finally check residence under paragraphs (e) and (ea).

For carer payment, work through s 198 as a checklist. Cover personal constant care, the ADAT score, private residence being the care receiver’s home, carer residence, and the care receiver’s income and assets.

Before deciding a carer payment claim fails because of a temporary absence, check ss 198AA to 198AC first.

For carer allowance, first ask if the care receiver is a child or an adult. For a child, consider s 953 and any route under s 954B. For an adult, distinguish s 954, which covers a shared home, from the separate-household route in s 954A. Only compare the ADAT threshold with whichever carer payment route actually applies.

Always cite the Impairment Tables and the ADAT as instruments. Never state a rate without the current instrument.

Self-check

Before relying on this area, check a few things.

Keep the three payments separate. Carer allowance is not simply a smaller version of carer payment.

Base your reasoning on points and functional capacity, not on diagnosis alone.

For carer payment, apply the means test to the care receiver, not the carer.

Check that the care is given in the right home, matching the right payment.

Finally, confirm which compilation of the Act you are citing.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.