Proportionality analysis

Why a structured test rather than simple balancing

Why not just weigh the right against the public interest? Courts avoid this simple balancing act. Proportionality analysis uses a structured test instead.

Simple balancing has two problems. It gives little guidance in advance, letting the decision-maker’s own views do all the work.

It also makes reasoning hard to test on appeal. A bare conclusion that one interest “outweighs” another cannot easily be challenged.

A staged test fixes this. It separates the inquiry into purpose, connection, and necessity. This lets reviewers pinpoint exactly where a government’s justification fails.

The structure of the test

Courts often test proportionality by asking a set sequence of questions. This structure matches the approach most High Court judges used in McCloy v New South Wales.

First, legitimate purpose: does the measure aim at a goal the law accepts as legitimate? A purpose that only disadvantages a group cannot justify the limit, no matter how well it works.

Second, rational connection: does the measure actually help achieve that purpose, based on logic and evidence? If it does not rationally advance the purpose, it cannot be justified, even if the purpose itself is legitimate.

Third, reasonable necessity, also called minimal impairment: does the measure go no further than reasonably needed? If a less restrictive option was reasonably available and would work just as well, the measure may not be proportionate. In McCloy’s test for the implied freedom, a measure fails necessity if there was an “obvious and compelling alternative” that restricts the freedom less. Where a statute sets out its own limitation test, that wording is applied instead.

McCloy adds a final stage: adequacy in balance, sometimes called proportionality in the strict sense. This asks whether the restriction on the right is out of proportion to the importance of the purpose, even if the measure passed the earlier stages. McCloy places this after an initial question about whether the purpose and means are legitimate, called compatibility testing.

Not every version of the test includes this balancing step explicitly. But it reflects a shared concern: a measure might pass every earlier stage yet still impose a burden too heavy for what it actually achieves.

The standing of the structure is now in question

In Hopper v Victoria [2026] HCA 11, Edelman J criticised the three-step structure (rational connection, reasonable necessity, adequacy in balance). He said the first and third steps do little work, and that structured proportionality “should now be treated as dead”. But this was only his view, not the Court’s.

What matters more is what the majority actually did. Gageler CJ, Gordon, Jagot and Beech-Jones JJ decided the case without using proportionality language at all. They asked instead whether the burden on the implied freedom was justified by a legitimate purpose.

No majority has said the three-step structure is wrong, so McCloy still stands as authority for it. But students should not treat the stages as a mandatory test. Instead, state the real legal question first, then use the stages as a tool to help answer it.

Working through the stages in order, where they apply

When a stage test applies, courts usually work through the stages in order. If a measure fails an earlier stage, courts generally don’t need to check the later ones.

For example, an illegitimate purpose can’t be fixed by good tailoring. A measure with no rational connection can’t be saved just because there was no less restrictive option.

Each stage must be passed on its own. It is not just one factor weighed in with others.

This sequence isn’t used everywhere. In implied freedom cases, courts don’t always have to use the stages expressly. A charter or Act’s limitation clause instead follows its own specific wording.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by naming the right said to be limited, and the measure that limits it.

Then work out which proportionality test applies. The exact test can differ depending on its source, so check whether it comes from a constitutional rule, a charter, or elsewhere.

Ask whether the measure has a legitimate purpose. Be specific about what that purpose actually is.

Ask whether the measure is rationally connected to that purpose. This means asking whether the measure actually helps achieve it.

Ask whether the measure goes no further than reasonably necessary. Identify any less restrictive alternative that was reasonably available.

Finally, apply whatever the source test requires. If it sets out stages, work through them in order, rather than jumping to an overall impression. In an implied freedom case, the stages are a tool, and what matters most is that the justification is reasoned, not just asserted.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.