International human rights instruments
Dualism: ratification is not incorporation
Australia keeps international law and domestic law separate. This is called a dualist approach.
The Commonwealth executive can ratify a treaty, binding Australia internationally. But ratifying a treaty does not automatically make it part of Australian domestic law.
For courts to directly enforce a treaty, it generally must be incorporated. Incorporation means Parliament passes legislation giving the treaty’s terms legal effect in Australia.
This has a key consequence. Australia may be bound by a treaty internationally, yet it may create no enforceable rights domestically if Parliament has not incorporated it.
A person cannot simply rely on an unincorporated treaty’s text. They cannot ask a court to enforce it as if it were a statute.
Where incorporation has happened
Incorporation doesn’t work the same way for every treaty. Australia decides this treaty by treaty, and sometimes only part of a treaty gets incorporated.
Some Commonwealth laws, including parts of the anti-discrimination Acts, were written to put particular treaty obligations into Australian law.
When this happens, you enforce the right through that domestic Act, not the treaty itself. The Act is the real source of the enforceable right.
Indirect influence where a treaty is not incorporated
An unincorporated treaty (one Australia has not written into domestic law) is not irrelevant. Australia still promised to honour it internationally, so it can shape Australian law indirectly, in two main ways.
First, statutory interpretation. If legislation is unclear, courts will generally choose a reading that fits Australia’s international obligations. This is because Parliament is assumed not to break its treaty promises, unless it clearly says otherwise.
Second, administrative decision-making. A decision-maker is not barred from considering a ratified treaty just because it is unincorporated. In Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Teoh, Mason CJ and Deane J said there was no reason to exclude it from consideration. But whether it actually matters to a particular decision is a separate question, and the treaty does not itself give the person an enforceable right.
Teoh also said ratifying a treaty could create a legitimate expectation (an assumption that officials will follow it), triggering procedural fairness. That part of Teoh no longer applies. In Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v WZARH, the High Court held legitimate expectation is not the test for whether or how procedural fairness applies.
So what remains from Teoh is narrower: decision-makers may still consider an unincorporated treaty. Students should argue real unfairness in the process, not a disappointed expectation.
In both situations, the treaty works in the background. It helps shape how existing law is interpreted or applied, rather than giving people rights they can enforce directly.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.