Human rights charters and Acts
The dialogue model
Charters or Acts like this usually follow the dialogue model. The High Court discussed this model in Momcilovic v The Queen (2011) 245 CLR 1. It differs from a constitutional bill of rights, which lets courts strike down legislation.
Under the dialogue model, public authorities (government bodies and officials doing public functions) must act compatibly with listed rights. They must also properly consider those rights when deciding things.
Courts and tribunals must interpret legislation compatibly with those rights, so far as possible given the legislation’s purpose. This is an interpretive duty, not an absolute requirement.
If legislation truly cannot be read compatibly, courts usually cannot strike it down. Instead, a declaration of incompatibility sends the issue back to Parliament, which decides whether to change the law.
This is called a “dialogue” because courts do not have the final word. Responsibility is shared between courts, the executive and Parliament, with Parliament keeping ultimate control. It is an important rights model, but materially different from a constitutional bill of rights.
Most jurisdictions have no such instrument
Don’t overstate how common this is. Some Australian jurisdictions have their own charter or Act protecting human rights.
But most Australian jurisdictions have no general human rights instrument at all.
Which jurisdictions have one can change over time. Always check the current position, rather than relying on a fixed list.
Protection where there is no charter or Act
No charter or Act? That does not mean no rights protection. Other legal tools still apply.
Commonwealth anti-discrimination Acts apply nationally. They work even where a jurisdiction has no charter of its own.
The general law also helps. This includes common law doctrines that limit executive power and protect procedural fairness (fair treatment in decision-making processes).
Some constitutional protections exist too, both express and implied. These apply across Australia but are narrower than a general bill of rights.
So a missing charter is not the whole picture. It is just one layer in a bigger structure of rights protection.
Interpretive obligations in practice
When a charter or Act applies, its interpretive obligation usually matters most in practice. This obligation requires courts to prefer a reading of legislation that fits with rights, but only where the text allows it.
So the charter or Act mostly works by shaping how existing laws are read. It also affects how public authorities make decisions and explain their reasons. It rarely creates brand-new legal claims on its own.
In Director of Public Prosecutions (Vic) v Smith [2024] HCA 32, the High Court restated this approach. At [57], the majority explained that s 32(1) requires legislation to be read compatibly with Charter rights “so far as it is possible to do so consistently with its purpose.”
This means that if the plain text allows more than one reading, courts must prefer the rights-compatible one. But the provision only guides interpretation. It does not let courts give the text a meaning it cannot reasonably bear.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by working out which jurisdiction the conduct or decision happened in. This matters because human rights protection differs between jurisdictions.
Check whether that jurisdiction actually has its own human rights charter or Act. Do not assume it does, and do not assume it does not — check first.
If it does have one, find the relevant right. Then ask whether a public authority is involved, and whether the interpretive obligation can give the legislation a rights-compatible reading. The interpretive obligation is a rule requiring courts to read legislation, where possible, in a way consistent with the right.
If the jurisdiction has no charter or Act, look for another layer of protection instead. This could be a Commonwealth anti-discrimination Act, a constitutional provision, or the general law.
Finally, do not assume a remedy exists just because a right is engaged. Check what the actual instrument says — or, if there is no instrument, whether anything else provides one.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.