Homicide

The physical element and causation

The prosecution must prove the accused’s act or omission caused the death. The accused’s conduct need not be the only cause. It must be a substantial or operating cause.

The eggshell skull principle applies here. This means the accused takes the victim as they find them. An unusual vulnerability in the victim does not break the chain of causation.

Intervening acts can break the chain of causation. These include medical treatment, the victim’s own escape attempts, or a third party stepping in. But they only break the chain if they are so independent and significant that the accused’s contribution becomes insignificant. Negligent medical treatment usually does not break the chain.

An omission (a failure to act) only creates liability if the accused had a legal duty to act. This duty can come from a relationship, from taking on a caring role, or from creating the danger in the first place.

Murder

Murder needs a killing, plus one of several fault elements. These include intending to kill, or intending to cause grievous bodily harm (really serious injury).

Another fault element is reckless indifference to human life. This means foreseeing death, or in some jurisdictions grievous bodily harm, as a probable result.

The last is constructive (or felony) murder. Here, death results from committing another serious offence, without needing to prove any intention about the death.

Constructive murder is the most distinctive and variable category. It exists in some jurisdictions but not others, and where it applies, the qualifying offences are specifically defined.

Voluntary manslaughter: the partial defences

Sometimes murder’s fault element is proven, but a partial defence applies. This lowers the verdict from murder to manslaughter, called voluntary manslaughter. The defences vary between jurisdictions.

Provocation is one such defence. Many places have abolished it or limited it heavily, after criticism that it excused killings in domestic settings.

Substantial impairment, also called diminished responsibility, is another. It applies where an abnormality of mind substantially impaired the accused’s capacity.

Excessive self-defence can also apply. This is where the accused believed force was necessary, but that belief was unreasonable.

These defences only reduce murder to manslaughter. They do not lead to full acquittal.

Involuntary manslaughter

Involuntary manslaughter applies when murder’s fault element is missing. There are two types.

Unlawful and dangerous act manslaughter needs an unlawful act, meaning a criminal offence, not just a tort. A reasonable person in the accused’s position must have realised this act risked serious injury to someone. This test is objective, so the accused’s own awareness of the risk does not matter.

Criminal negligence manslaughter needs a breach of a duty of care. The breach must fall far below what a reasonable person would do, and carry a high risk of death or grievous bodily harm. This standard is much stricter than ordinary civil negligence.

Constructive and unlawful act murder

Several jurisdictions still have a form of murder called constructive, felony, or unlawful act murder. This applies when death results from, or occurs soon after, another serious offence.

Here, the fault element for murder (the mental state the prosecution must prove) comes from the fault element of that other offence. The prosecution does not need to separately prove any intention to kill.

The doctrine is limited. The base offence must carry a specified minimum penalty, and there must be a temporal and causal connection — meaning it must happen close in time to the death, and actually cause it.

Because this doctrine removes the need to prove fault for the death itself, courts read it narrowly. It is often the subject of appeals.

The unborn and the deceased

Quick Read: Homicide needs a victim who was born alive and existed independently. Harming a foetus is not homicide. It is covered by separate offences, which vary between jurisdictions, or by aggravated assault laws if the mother is harmed.

The accused’s act must actually cause death. You cannot kill someone who is already dead.

Sometimes the accused thinks the victim is dead and disposes of the body, but the person was still alive. Here courts look at the whole series of acts together, not just one isolated act, to decide the cause of death.

Other homicide offences

Most jurisdictions also recognise other homicide offences, beyond murder and manslaughter.

Infanticide applies when a mother causes her child’s death, under a set age. Her mind must have been disturbed by the effects of childbirth or lactation. It works both as a separate offence and as a partial defence to murder.

Dangerous or culpable driving causing death sits between manslaughter and ordinary traffic offences. It does not need the high degree of negligence that manslaughter requires.

Industrial manslaughter exists in most jurisdictions. It makes a corporate body or a senior officer liable for a workplace death caused by breaching a work health and safety duty. Its fault element and attribution rules come from work safety legislation, not from general homicide law.

Sentencing

Murder can lead to life imprisonment in every Australian jurisdiction. This is the maximum sentence, not the only one.

Some jurisdictions set a standard non-parole period for murder. A non-parole period is the minimum time served before parole is possible. Some also make life imprisonment mandatory for certain murders, such as killing a police officer.

Manslaughter has a much lower maximum sentence. It covers a wide range of conduct, from one unlucky push to prolonged gross negligence. Sentences vary widely to reflect this.

This is why partial defences matter so much. If a partial defence reduces murder to manslaughter, the life maximum no longer applies. The court can then use the full, wider sentencing range for manslaughter.

Applying this in a problem question

Start with death and causation. Causation means the accused’s act must have caused the death. Deal expressly with any intervening act, something that breaks the chain of causation.

Next, identify the jurisdiction. This matters because it decides which fault elements and partial defences apply.

Then work through the murder fault elements in order. Only consider constructive murder, murder based on an underlying act rather than intent to kill, if that jurisdiction recognises it.

If murder is established, consider each partial defence the facts raise. These can reduce murder to a lesser offence.

If murder is not established, consider involuntary manslaughter. Work through both routes separately, since they use different tests. Merging them loses marks.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.