Health care decision making in the Northern Territory

A hierarchy, not an appointment

The Northern Territory, like New South Wales, uses a statutory ranking to find a substitute decision-maker. No appointment is needed. Section 13 lists health care decision makers in order of priority.

First is a person given health care authority by the adult in an advance personal plan, or an equivalent interstate document. Second is a guardian with health care authority. Third is a relative recognised under Aboriginal or other customary law as the appropriate decision maker.

Fourth is a spouse or de facto partner with a close, continuing relationship with the adult. Fifth is a carer, as long as they are not paid to provide that care commercially.

Because the adult’s own choice ranks first, planning ahead overrides the default order.

The decision-making cascade

Section 18 sets out steps a decision maker must follow in the Northern Territory. It follows the same structure as the Advance Personal Planning Act 2013 (NT).

First, the decision maker must follow any advance care statement the adult made about the decision (s 18(2)). This is subject to ss 20(1) and 41(1)(e).

Second, if there is no advance care statement, the decision maker uses substituted judgement. This means deciding what the adult would have chosen, on reasonable grounds (s 18(3)).

Section 18(4) explains how to form that belief. The decision maker must consider the adult’s current and past wishes, views and objections, plus the decision maker’s own personal knowledge of the adult.

So the Territory uses one consistent approach in both its planning and health laws. Advance care statements come first, then substituted judgement based on personal knowledge of the adult.

Two hierarchies compared

The Northern Territory and New South Wales both set an order of who can make health care decisions for someone else. Both lists start with a person who was chosen or appointed, and both end with informal relationships, like a close friend.

The middle of each list differs. The Northern Territory includes a guardian, a relative identified by customary law, a spouse or de facto partner, and a non-commercial carer. It then uses a substituted judgement cascade, a process asking what the person themselves would have decided.

New South Wales instead lists a guardian with the treatment function, a spouse in a close and continuing relationship, and a person who has care of the person.

Only the Northern Territory list recognises customary law authority. This is a key difference between the two jurisdictions.

Applying this in a problem question

First check if the decision is a health care decision in the Northern Territory. If it is, this Act applies, not the guardianship principles.

Then work through the s 13 list of decision makers in order. Do not jump straight to the spouse by skipping paragraph (c).

If paragraph (c) applies, ask what the person’s customary law or tradition says is appropriate. This decides who should act.

Before finalising a decision maker, check ss 14 to 16. These cover whether the person is appropriate, what happens with multiple appointees, and relinquishment.

Next, apply s 18(2) first by asking if there is an advance care statement covering this decision.

If there is none, move to s 18(3), which asks what the person would have decided themselves. Then apply both parts of s 18(4), including the decision maker’s own personal knowledge of the person.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.