Guardianship and management of property in the ACT

Wishes must be given effect — with one threshold

Section 4(2)(b) in the ACT sets out a key rule for decision-makers. The protected person’s wishes, as far as they can be worked out, must be given effect to. This means the decision-maker must follow those wishes, not just consider them.

There is one exception. The decision-maker does not have to follow the wishes if doing so is likely to significantly adversely affect the protected person’s interests.

This exception has a high threshold. It is not a general best interests override. Ordinary disagreement, or a risk of some detriment, is not enough to trigger it.

Partial effect where the threshold is met

Quick Read: Section 4(2)(c) applies in the ACT when the threshold is met. This means giving effect to the person’s wishes would significantly adversely affect their interests.

Even then, the decision-maker is not off the hook. They must still follow the person’s wishes as far as possible, without causing that significant adverse effect. The ACT expects them to find the largest part of the wishes they can still carry out.

Only if the wishes cannot be worked out or followed at all does s 4(2)(d) apply. Then the decision-maker must promote the person’s interests instead. Interests are a last resort, not the main rule.

The remaining principles

This is about the ACT. Section 4(2)(e) says a protected person’s life should be interfered with as little as possible. This includes their lifestyle, not just formal decisions.

Section 4(2)(f) says the person should be encouraged to look after themselves, as far as possible. Section 4(2)(g) says they should be encouraged to live in and join the general community, as far as possible.

The mention of lifestyle in paragraph (e) matters. It shows the limit on interference covers everyday living, not only official decisions.

Consulting carers

Section 4(3) sets a duty. Before deciding, the decision-maker must consult each carer of the protected person.

Section 4(4) gives one exception. The decision-maker must not consult a carer if, in their opinion, this would adversely affect the protected person’s interests. This is a lower bar than the “significant adverse effect” test used elsewhere, for departing from the person’s wishes.

Section 4(5) makes clear this duty does not stop the decision-maker consulting others as well.

Applying this in a problem question

Work through this ACT problem in order. First check s 4(2)(a): did the person get support to help them understand, take part and communicate?

Next, try to work out the person’s wishes. The starting point is a duty to give effect to those wishes.

Then apply the threshold carefully. It asks whether there is a likelihood of significant adverse effect on the person’s interests. Mere detriment or disagreement is not enough.

If that threshold is met, move to s 4(2)(c). Work out how much of the person’s wishes can still be given effect, even with that risk.

Only turn to s 4(2)(d), promoting the person’s interests, if their wishes cannot be worked out at all, or cannot be given effect at all.

Finally, consider the s 4(3) duty to consult each carer, remembering the narrower exception in s 4(4).

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.