Guardianship and administration in Western Australia

Best interests as the primary concern

Section 4(2) sets the test in Western Australia. The Tribunal’s primary concern is the best interests of the represented person, or a person an application concerns.

This wording matters. “Best interests” is not the same as will and preferences, substituted judgment, or welfare and interests.

It is also the “primary concern,” not the “paramount consideration.” New South Wales uses “paramount consideration” instead.

Both are protective standards, but they differ slightly. A student should quote the WA section directly, not borrow wording from another State’s Act.

Ascertaining views and wishes

Quick Read: Ascertaining views and wishes (Western Australia)

Section 4(7) tells the Tribunal to try to find out the person’s views and wishes. This applies “as far as possible”.

These views can come from how the person expressed them, in any manner. Non-verbal communication counts too.

The Tribunal can also look at the person’s previous actions. This means past conduct can show what someone currently wants, even after losing capacity.

The duty is to actively seek these views, not just accept whatever is volunteered. This is a positive obligation, not a passive one.

Under s 4(2), best interests remain the main concern. But s 4(7) means the Tribunal must still actively search for the person’s own views when deciding what is best for them.

The elements of a guardianship order

This passage is about Western Australia’s guardianship law. Section 43(1) lets the Tribunal declare that a person needs a guardian, but only if certain things are satisfied, and subject to s 4.

First, the person must be 18 or older. Second, under paragraph (b), the Tribunal must be satisfied of one of three things: the person cannot look after their own health and safety; or cannot make reasonable judgments about personal matters; or needs oversight, care or control for their own health and safety or to protect others. Third, the person must actually need a guardian.

The third option in paragraph (b) is protective. It is broader than simple incapacity, because it can apply even if the person is not incapable, so long as oversight protects them or others. The passage treats this as a separate route into the jurisdiction, not just another form of incapacity.

Section 43(2) adds a further requirement. When the Tribunal declares someone needs a guardian, it must also state which specific paragraph (b) ground it relied on. The reasoning behind the order must be recorded, not just the final conclusion.

Section 43(2a) allows an early order. If a person is 17, the Tribunal may still make an order, provided it is satisfied the person will meet the criteria once they turn 18.

Applying this in a problem question

When answering a problem question on guardianship in Western Australia, work through these steps in order.

First, identify which of the four s 4(3) domains applies. Then ask whether the presumption has been displaced for that domain.

Next, apply s 4(4): could less restrictive means meet the person’s needs? If so, no order should be made.

Only if an order is still needed, choose between plenary (full) and limited guardianship under s 4(5), then set its terms under s 4(6).

For s 43(1)(b), identify which limb is relied on. Name the oversight-and-protection limb if that is the one used.

Under s 43(2), the Tribunal must state which matters it is satisfied of.

Finally, under s 4(7), look for the person’s views, however expressed, and for evidence from their past actions.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.